Division of Pediatric Neurology, Department of Neurology, Washington University School of Medicine and St. Louis Children's Hospital, St. Louis, MO, USA.
Dev Med Child Neurol. 2021 Jun;63(6):748-754. doi: 10.1111/dmcn.14802. Epub 2021 Jan 7.
To determine the features cited by motor phenotyping experts when identifying dystonia in people with cerebral palsy (CP).
Dystonia identification in CP, particularly when comorbid with spasticity, can be difficult. The dystonia diagnostic criterion standard remains subjective visual identification by expert consensus. For this qualitative study, we conducted an inductive thematic analysis of consensus-building discussions between three pediatric movement disorder physicians as they identified the presence or absence of dystonia in gait videos of 40 participants with spastic CP and periventricular leukomalacia.
Unanimous consensus about the presence or absence of dystonia was achieved for 34 out of 40 videos. Two main themes were present during consensus-building discussions as videos were evaluated for dystonia: (1) unilateral leg or foot adduction that was variable over time, and (2) difficulty in identifying dystonia. Codes contributing to the first theme were more likely to be cited by a discussant when they felt dystonia was present (as opposed to absent) in a video (χ test, p=0.004).
These results describe the gait features cited by experts during consensus-building discussion as they identify dystonia in ambulatory people with CP. Qualitative thematic analysis of these discussions could help codify the subjective process of dystonia diagnosis.
确定运动表型专家在识别脑瘫(CP)患者的肌张力障碍时所引用的特征。
CP 中的肌张力障碍识别,特别是在合并痉挛时,可能很困难。肌张力障碍的诊断标准仍然是专家共识的主观视觉识别。在这项定性研究中,我们对三位儿科运动障碍医生在识别存在或不存在步态视频中的肌张力障碍时进行了共识建立讨论进行了归纳主题分析,这些视频来自 40 名患有痉挛性 CP 和脑室周围白质软化症的参与者。
在 40 个视频中有 34 个视频达成了关于肌张力障碍存在与否的一致意见。在评估视频是否存在肌张力障碍时,共识建立讨论中存在两个主要主题:(1)单侧腿部或脚部内收,且随时间变化;(2)难以识别肌张力障碍。当讨论者认为视频中存在(而非不存在)肌张力障碍时,更有可能引用第一主题的代码(卡方检验,p=0.004)。
这些结果描述了专家在共识建立讨论中确定 CP 患者运动时所引用的步态特征。对这些讨论进行定性主题分析可以帮助编纂肌张力障碍诊断的主观过程。