McClarty Leigh M, Blanchard James F, Becker Marissa L
Institute for Global Public Health, Rady Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Manitoba, R065 Medical Rehabilitation Building, 771 McDermot Ave, Winnipeg, MB, R3E 0T6, Canada.
BMC Public Health. 2021 Feb 4;21(1):281. doi: 10.1186/s12889-021-10225-w.
Manitoba is a central Canadian province with annual rates of new HIV infections consistently higher than the Canadian average. National surveillance statistics and data from the provincial HIV care program suggest that epidemiological heterogeneity exists across Manitoba. New HIV cases are disproportionately reported among females, Indigenous-identifying individuals, and those with a history of injection drug use. Given the heterogeneity in acquisition, it is of interest to understand whether this translates into inequalities in HIV care across Manitoba.
A sample of 703 participants from a clinical cohort of people living with HIV in Manitoba, with data current to the end of 2017, was used to conduct cross-sectional, disaggregated analyses of the HIV care cascade to identify heterogeneity in service coverage and clinical outcomes among different groups receiving HIV care in Manitoba. Equiplots are used to identify and visualize inequalities across the cascade. Exploratory multivariable logistic regression models quantify associations between equity variables (age, sex, geography, ethnicity, immigration status, exposure category) and progression along the cascade. Adjusted odds ratios (AOR) and 95% confidence intervals (95%CI) are reported.
Equity analyses highlight inequalities in engagement in and coverage of HIV-related health services among cohort participants. Equiplots illustrate that the proportion of participants in each cascade step is greater for those who are older, white, non-immigrants, and report no history of injection drug use. Compared to those living in Winnipeg, participants in eastern Manitoba have greater odds of achieving virologic suppression (AOR[95%CI] = 3.8[1.3-11.2]). The odds of Indigenous participants being virologically suppressed is half that of white participants (AOR[95%CI] = 0.5[0.3-0.7]), whereas African/Caribbean/Black participants are significantly less likely than white participants to be in care and retained in care (AOR[95%CI] = 0.3[0.2-0.7] and 0.4[0.2-0.9], respectively).
Inequalities exist across the cascade for different groups of Manitobans living with HIV; equiplots are an innovative method for visualizing these inequalities. Alongside future research aiming to understand why inequalities exist across the cascade in Manitoba, our equity analyses can generate hypotheses and provide evidence to inform patient-centred care plans that meet the needs of diverse client subgroups and advocate for policy changes that facilitate more equitable HIV care across the province.
曼尼托巴省是加拿大中部的一个省份,其每年新增艾滋病毒感染率一直高于加拿大平均水平。全国监测统计数据和该省艾滋病毒护理项目的数据表明,曼尼托巴省存在流行病学异质性。新的艾滋病毒病例在女性、自我认定为原住民的个体以及有注射吸毒史的人群中报告比例过高。鉴于感染情况的异质性,了解这是否会转化为曼尼托巴省艾滋病毒护理方面的不平等现象很有意义。
从曼尼托巴省一个艾滋病毒感染者临床队列中抽取703名参与者作为样本,使用截至2017年底的数据,对艾滋病毒护理流程进行横断面、分类分析,以确定在曼尼托巴省接受艾滋病毒护理的不同群体之间服务覆盖范围和临床结果的异质性。使用等值图来识别和可视化整个护理流程中的不平等现象。探索性多变量逻辑回归模型量化公平变量(年龄、性别、地理位置、种族、移民身份、暴露类别)与护理流程进展之间的关联。报告调整后的比值比(AOR)和95%置信区间(95%CI)。
公平性分析突出了队列参与者在参与艾滋病毒相关健康服务和服务覆盖方面的不平等现象。等值图表明,在每个护理流程步骤中,年龄较大、白人、非移民且无注射吸毒史的参与者比例更高。与居住在温尼伯的参与者相比,曼尼托巴省东部的参与者实现病毒抑制的几率更高(AOR[95%CI]=3.8[1.3 - 11.2])。原住民参与者实现病毒抑制的几率是白人参与者的一半(AOR[95%CI]=0.5[0.3 - 0.7]),而非洲/加勒比/黑人参与者接受护理并持续接受护理的可能性明显低于白人参与者(分别为AOR[95%CI]=0.3[0.2 - 0.7]和0.4[0.2 - 0.9])。
对于曼尼托巴省不同的艾滋病毒感染者群体,整个护理流程中都存在不平等现象;等值图是一种可视化这些不平等现象的创新方法。除了未来旨在了解曼尼托巴省护理流程中为何存在不平等现象的研究之外;我们的公平性分析可以生成假设并提供证据,为以患者为中心的护理计划提供参考,以满足不同客户亚群体的需求,并倡导政策变革,以促进全省更公平的艾滋病毒护理。