Associate Professor, Community Health Sciences, Jonathan and Karin Fielding School of Public Health, University of California Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA, USA. Correspondence:
Associate Director, Institute for Global Health Sciences, University of California, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Sex Reprod Health Matters. 2021 Dec;29(1):1-15. doi: 10.1080/26410397.2021.1892570.
Poor quality person-centred maternity care (PCMC) leads to delays in care and adverse maternal and newborn outcomes. This study describes the impact of spreading a Change Package, or interventions that other health facilities had previously piloted and identified as successful, to improve PCMC in public health facilities in Uttar Pradesh, India. A quasi-experimental design was used including matched control-intervention facilities and pre-post data collection. This study took place in Uttar Pradesh, India in 2018-2019. Six large public health facilities participated in the evaluation of the spread study, including three intervention and three control facilities. Intervention facilities were introduced to a quality improvement (QI) Change Package to improve PCMC. In total, 1200 women participated in the study, including 600 women at baseline and 600 women at endline. Difference-in-difference estimators are used to examine the impact of spreading a QI Change Package across spread sites vs. control sites and at baseline and endline using a validated PCMC scale. Out of a 100-point scale, a 24.93 point improvement was observed in overall PCMC scores among spread facilities compared to control facilities from baseline to endline (95% CI: 22.29, 27.56). For the eight PCMC indicators that the Change Package targeted, spread facilities increased 33.86 points (95% CI: 30.91, 36.81) relative to control facilities across survey rounds. Findings suggest that spread of a PCMC Change Package results in improved experiences of care for women as well as secondary outcomes, including clinical quality, nurse and doctor visits, and decreases in delivery problems.Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT04208841..
较差的以人为主的孕产护理质量(PCMC)会导致护理延误以及产妇和新生儿不良结局。本研究描述了在印度北方邦的公立卫生机构中推广变革方案(或其他卫生机构先前试点并确定为成功的干预措施)以改善 PCMC 的效果。采用了准实验设计,包括匹配的对照-干预设施和预-后数据收集。本研究于 2018-2019 年在印度北方邦进行。六家大型公立卫生机构参与了推广研究的评估,包括三家干预机构和三家对照机构。干预机构引入了质量改进(QI)变革方案,以改善 PCMC。共有 1200 名妇女参与了研究,其中 600 名妇女在基线时,600 名妇女在终点时。采用经过验证的 PCMC 量表,使用差异-差异估计量来检验在推广地点与对照地点以及在基线和终点推广 QI 变革方案的效果。在 100 分制中,与对照机构相比,推广机构的整体 PCMC 评分从基线到终点提高了 24.93 分(95%CI:22.29,27.56)。在变革方案针对的八个 PCMC 指标中,与对照机构相比,推广机构在各轮调查中提高了 33.86 分(95%CI:30.91,36.81)。研究结果表明,推广 PCMC 变革方案可改善妇女的护理体验以及其他次要结果,包括临床质量、护士和医生访视以及分娩问题的减少。试验注册:ClinicalTrials.gov 标识符:NCT04208841。