Eltareb Ali, Lopez Gustavo E, Giovambattista Nicolas
Department of Physics, Brooklyn College of the City University of New York, Brooklyn, NY 11210, USA.
Phys Chem Chem Phys. 2021 Mar 21;23(11):6914-6928. doi: 10.1039/d0cp04325g. Epub 2021 Mar 17.
We perform path-integral molecular dynamics (PIMD) simulations of HO and DO using the q-TIP4P/F model. Simulations are performed at P = 1 bar and over a wide range of temperatures that include the equilibrium (T≥ 273 K) and supercooled (210 ≤T < 273 K) liquid states of water. The densities of both HO and DO calculated from PIMD simulations are in excellent agreement with experiments in the equilibrium and supercooled regimes. We also evaluate important thermodynamic response functions, specifically, the thermal expansion coefficient α(T), isothermal compressibility κ(T), isobaric heat capacity C(T), and static dielectric constant ε(T). While these properties are in excellent [α(T) and κ(T)] or semi-quantitative agreement [C(T) and ε(T)] with experiments in the equilibrium regime, they are increasingly underestimated upon further cooling. It follows that the inclusion of nuclear quantum effects in PIMD simulations of (q-TIP4P/F) water is not sufficient to reproduce the anomalous large fluctuations in density, entropy, and electric dipole moment characteristic of supercooled water. It has been hypothesized that water may exhibit a liquid-liquid critical point (LLCP) in the supercooled regime at P > 1 bar and that such a LLCP generates a maximum in C(T) and κ(T) at 1 bar. Consistent with this hypothesis and in particular, with experiments, we find a maximum in the κ(T) of q-TIP4P/F light and heavy water at T≈ 230-235 K. No maximum in C(T) could be detected down to T≥ 210 K. We also calculate the diffusion coefficient D(T) of HO and DO using the ring-polymer molecular dynamics (RPMD) technique and find that computer simulations are in remarkable good agreement with experiments at all temperatures studied. The results from RPMD/PIMD simulations are also compared with the corresponding results obtained from classical MD simulations of q-TIP4P/F water where atoms are represented by single interacting sites. Surprisingly, we find minor differences in most of the properties studied, with C(T), D(T), and structural properties being the only (expected) exceptions.
我们使用q-TIP4P/F模型对H₂O和D₂O进行路径积分分子动力学(PIMD)模拟。模拟在P = 1巴的压力下进行,温度范围广泛,包括水的平衡态(T≥273 K)和过冷态(210≤T < 273 K)液态。从PIMD模拟计算得到的H₂O和D₂O的密度在平衡态和过冷态下与实验结果高度吻合。我们还评估了重要的热力学响应函数,具体来说,热膨胀系数α(T)、等温压缩率κ(T)、等压热容C(T)和静态介电常数ε(T)。虽然这些性质在平衡态下与实验结果高度吻合[α(T)和κ(T)]或半定量一致[C(T)和ε(T)],但随着进一步冷却,它们越来越被低估。由此可见,在(q-TIP4P/F)水的PIMD模拟中纳入核量子效应不足以再现过冷水密度、熵和电偶极矩的异常大波动。据推测,在P > 1巴的过冷态下,水可能会出现液-液临界点(LLCP),并且这样的LLCP会在1巴时使C(T)和κ(T)出现最大值。与该假设一致,特别是与实验结果一致,我们发现在T≈230 - 235 K时,q-TIP4P/F轻水和重水的κ(T)出现最大值。在低至T≥210 K时未检测到C(T)的最大值。我们还使用环聚合物分子动力学(RPMD)技术计算了H₂O和D₂O的扩散系数D(T),发现在所有研究温度下计算机模拟与实验结果都非常吻合。RPMD/PIMD模拟结果也与从q-TIP4P/F水的经典分子动力学(MD)模拟得到的相应结果进行了比较,其中原子由单个相互作用位点表示。令人惊讶的是,我们发现在大多数研究性质中差异较小,C(T)、D(T)和结构性质是唯一(预期的)例外。