Xiao Ran, Do Duc, Ding Cheng, Meisel Karl, Lee Randall, Hu Xiao
School of Nursing, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA 94143 USA.
School of Nursing, Duke University, Durham, NC 27708 USA.
IEEE Access. 2020;8:132404-132412. doi: 10.1109/access.2020.3009667. Epub 2020 Jul 16.
Bedside patient monitors are ubiquitous tools in modern critical care units to provide timely patient status. However, current systems suffer from high volume of false alarms leading to alarm fatigue, one of top technical hazards in clinical settings. Many studies are racing to develop improved algorithms towards precision patient monitoring, while little has been done to investigate the aspect of algorithm generalizability across different health institutions. Our group has been developing an evolving framework termed SuperAlarm that extracts multivariate patterns in data streams (monitor alarms, electronic health records and physiologic waveforms) of modern health enterprise to predict patient deterioration and has demonstrated great potential in mitigating alarm fatigue. In this study, we further investigate the generalizability of SuperAlarm by designing a comprehensive approach to achieve performance comparison in predicting in-hospital code blue (CB) events across two health institutions. SuperAlarm model trained with alarm data in one institution is tested on both internal and external test sets. Results show comparable performance with sensitivity up to 80% within one-hour window of events and over 90% in reduction of false alarms in both institutions. Cross-institutional performance agreement can be further improved by predicting a more stringent CB subtype (cardiopulmonary arrest), with internal sensitivity lying within 95% confident interval of external one up to 8-hour before event onset. The cross-institutional performance comparison offers first-hand knowledge on both advantages and challenges in generalizing a prediction algorithm across different institutions, which hold key information to guide the design of model training and deployment strategy.
床边患者监护仪是现代重症监护病房中用于及时提供患者状况的普遍工具。然而,当前系统存在大量误报,导致警报疲劳,这是临床环境中最主要的技术风险之一。许多研究竞相开发改进算法以实现精准患者监测,而在研究算法在不同医疗机构中的通用性方面却做得很少。我们团队一直在开发一个名为SuperAlarm的不断演进的框架,该框架可从现代医疗企业的数据流(监护警报、电子健康记录和生理波形)中提取多变量模式,以预测患者病情恶化,并已在减轻警报疲劳方面展现出巨大潜力。在本研究中,我们通过设计一种综合方法,在两个医疗机构中对预测院内蓝色急救(CB)事件的性能进行比较,进一步研究SuperAlarm的通用性。在一个机构中使用警报数据训练的SuperAlarm模型在内部和外部测试集上进行测试。结果显示,在事件发生的一小时窗口内,敏感性高达80%,两个机构的误报减少率均超过90%,性能相当。通过预测更严格的CB亚型(心肺骤停),跨机构性能一致性可进一步提高,在事件发生前8小时内,内部敏感性处于外部敏感性的95%置信区间内。跨机构性能比较为在不同机构中推广预测算法的优势和挑战提供了第一手信息,这些信息对指导模型训练和部署策略的设计至关重要。