Bouget David, Pedersen André, Hosainey Sayied Abdol Mohieb, Vanel Johanna, Solheim Ole, Reinertsen Ingerid
SINTEF, Medical Technology Department, Trondheim, Norway.
Bristol Royal Hospital for Children, Department of Neurosurgery, Bristol, United Kingdom.
J Med Imaging (Bellingham). 2021 Mar;8(2):024002. doi: 10.1117/1.JMI.8.2.024002. Epub 2021 Mar 26.
Automatic and consistent meningioma segmentation in T1-weighted magnetic resonance (MR) imaging volumes and corresponding volumetric assessment is of use for diagnosis, treatment planning, and tumor growth evaluation. We optimized the segmentation and processing speed performances using a large number of both surgically treated meningiomas and untreated meningiomas followed at the outpatient clinic. We studied two different three-dimensional (3D) neural network architectures: (i) a simple encoder-decoder similar to a 3D U-Net, and (ii) a lightweight multi-scale architecture [Pulmonary Lobe Segmentation Network (PLS-Net)]. In addition, we studied the impact of different training schemes. For the validation studies, we used 698 T1-weighted MR volumes from St. Olav University Hospital, Trondheim, Norway. The models were evaluated in terms of detection accuracy, segmentation accuracy, and training/inference speed. While both architectures reached a similar Dice score of 70% on average, the PLS-Net was more accurate with an -score of up to 88%. The highest accuracy was achieved for the largest meningiomas. Speed-wise, the PLS-Net architecture tended to converge in about 50 h while 130 h were necessary for U-Net. Inference with PLS-Net takes less than a second on GPU and about 15 s on CPU. Overall, with the use of mixed precision training, it was possible to train competitive segmentation models in a relatively short amount of time using the lightweight PLS-Net architecture. In the future, the focus should be brought toward the segmentation of small meningiomas ( ) to improve clinical relevance for automatic and early diagnosis and speed of growth estimates.
在T1加权磁共振(MR)成像容积中进行自动且一致的脑膜瘤分割以及相应的容积评估,对于诊断、治疗规划和肿瘤生长评估具有重要意义。我们利用大量经手术治疗的脑膜瘤和在门诊随访的未经治疗的脑膜瘤,优化了分割和处理速度性能。我们研究了两种不同的三维(3D)神经网络架构:(i)一种类似于3D U-Net的简单编码器-解码器,以及(ii)一种轻量级多尺度架构[肺叶分割网络(PLS-Net)]。此外,我们还研究了不同训练方案的影响。在验证研究中,我们使用了来自挪威特隆赫姆圣奥拉夫大学医院的698个T1加权MR容积。从检测准确率、分割准确率以及训练/推理速度方面对模型进行了评估。虽然两种架构平均Dice分数相似,均达到70%,但PLS-Net更准确,最高 -分数可达88%。对于最大的脑膜瘤,准确率最高。在速度方面,PLS-Net架构大约在50小时内趋于收敛,而U-Net则需要130小时。在GPU上,使用PLS-Net进行推理不到1秒,在CPU上约为15秒。总体而言,通过使用混合精度训练,使用轻量级PLS-Net架构能够在相对较短的时间内训练出具有竞争力的分割模型。未来,应将重点转向小脑膜瘤( )的分割,以提高自动早期诊断和生长速度估计的临床相关性。