Division of Health Policy and Management, University of Minnesota School of Public Health, Minneapolis, MN, United States.
Department of Kinesiology and Community Health, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana-Champaign, IL, United States.
J Med Internet Res. 2021 May 10;23(5):e22549. doi: 10.2196/22549.
Older adults are increasingly accessing information and communicating using patient-facing portals available through their providers' electronic health record (EHR). Most theories of technology acceptance and use suggest that patients' overall satisfaction with care should be independent of their chosen level of portal engagement. However, achieving expected benefits of portal use depends on demonstrated support from providers to meet these expectations. This is especially true among older adults, who may require more guidance. However, little is known about whether misalignment of expectations around technology-facilitated care is associated with lower perceptions of care quality.
The aims of this study were to analyze whether older adults' assessment of primary care quality differs across levels of patient portal engagement and whether perceptions of how well their provider uses the EHR to support care moderates this relationship.
We conducted a cross-sectional survey analysis of 158 older adults over the age of 65 (average age 71.4 years) across Michigan using a 13-measure composite of self-assessed health care quality. Portal use was categorized as none, moderate (use of 1-3 functionalities), or extensive (use of 4-7 functionalities). EHR value perception was measured by asking respondents how they felt their doctor's EHR use improved the patient-provider relationship.
Moderate portal users, compared to those who were extensive users, had lower estimated care quality (-0.214 on 4-point scale; P=.03). Differences between extensive portal users and nonportal users were not significant. Quality perception was only particularly low among moderate portal users with low EHR value perception; those with high EHR value perception rated quality similarly to other portal user groups.
Older adults who are moderate portal users are the least satisfied with their care, and the most sensitive to perceptions of how well their provider uses the EHR to support the relationship. Encouraging portal use without compromising perceptions of quality requires thinking beyond patient-focused education. Achieving value from use of patient-facing technologies with older adults is contingent upon matched organizational investments that support technology-enabled care delivery. Providers and staff need policies and practices that demonstrate technology adeptness. Older adults may need more tailored signaling and accommodation for technology to be maximally impactful.
老年人越来越多地通过他们的医疗服务提供者的电子健康记录 (EHR) 中的面向患者的门户获取信息和进行沟通。大多数技术接受和使用理论表明,患者对护理的总体满意度不应取决于他们选择的门户参与程度。然而,实现门户使用的预期效益取决于提供者为满足这些期望提供的支持。这在老年人中尤其如此,他们可能需要更多的指导。然而,对于技术辅助护理的期望不一致是否与对护理质量的感知较低有关,目前知之甚少。
本研究旨在分析老年人对初级保健质量的评估是否因患者门户参与程度的不同而有所不同,以及他们对提供者使用 EHR 支持护理的看法是否会调节这种关系。
我们对密歇根州的 158 名 65 岁以上(平均年龄 71.4 岁)的老年人进行了横断面调查分析,使用自我评估的医疗保健质量的 13 项综合措施。门户使用情况分为无、中度(使用 1-3 种功能)和广泛(使用 4-7 种功能)。EHR 价值感知通过询问受访者他们对医生使用 EHR 改善医患关系的感受来衡量。
与广泛使用门户的患者相比,中度使用门户的患者估计的护理质量较低(4 分制中差 0.214 分;P=0.03)。广泛使用门户的患者与非门户使用者之间的差异不显著。仅在中度使用门户且对 EHR 价值感知较低的患者中,质量感知特别低;对 EHR 价值感知较高的患者对质量的评价与其他门户用户群体相似。
中度使用门户的老年人对他们的护理最不满意,对提供者使用 EHR 支持关系的感知最为敏感。在不影响对质量的感知的情况下,鼓励门户的使用需要超越以患者为中心的教育。要从老年人使用面向患者的技术中获得价值,需要进行匹配的组织投资,以支持技术驱动的护理交付。提供者和工作人员需要有政策和实践来展示技术能力。对于老年人来说,可能需要更有针对性的信号和适应,以便技术能够产生最大的影响。