Infantes-Paniagua Álvaro, Silva Ana Filipa, Ramirez-Campillo Rodrigo, Sarmento Hugo, González-Fernández Francisco Tomás, González-Víllora Sixto, Clemente Filipe Manuel
Department of Physical Education, Arts Education, and Music, Faculty of Education of Albacete, University of Castilla-La Mancha, 02071 Albacete, Spain.
N2i, Polytechnic Institute of Maia, 4475-690 Maia, Portugal.
Brain Sci. 2021 May 21;11(6):675. doi: 10.3390/brainsci11060675.
School physical activity breaks are currently being proposed as a way to improve students' learning. However, there is no clear evidence of the effects of active school breaks on academic-related cognitive outcomes. The present systematic review with meta-analysis scrutinized and synthesized the literature related to the effects of active breaks on students' attention. On January 12th, 2021, PubMed, PsycINFO, Scopus, SPORTDiscus, and Web of Science were searched for published interventions with counterbalanced cross-over or parallel-groups designs with a control group, including school-based active breaks, objective attentional outcomes, and healthy students of any age. Studies' results were qualitatively synthesized, and meta-analyses were performed if at least three study groups provided pre-post data for the same measure. Results showed some positive acute and chronic effects of active breaks on attentional outcomes (i.e., accuracy, concentration, inhibition, and sustained attention), especially on selective attention. However, most of the results were not significant. The small number of included studies and their heterogeneous design are the primary limitations of the present study. Although the results do not clearly point out the positive effects of active breaks, they do not compromise students' attention. The key roles of intensity and the leader of the active break are discussed. INPLASY registration number: 202110054.
目前有人提议利用学校体育活动课间休息来提高学生的学习效果。然而,尚无明确证据表明学校积极课间休息对与学业相关的认知成果有何影响。本项带有荟萃分析的系统评价对与积极课间休息对学生注意力影响相关的文献进行了审查和综合分析。2021年1月12日,在PubMed、PsycINFO、Scopus、SPORTDiscus和科学网中检索了已发表的干预措施,这些干预措施采用了带有对照组的平衡交叉或平行组设计,包括校内积极课间休息、客观注意力成果以及任何年龄的健康学生。对研究结果进行了定性综合分析,如果至少有三个研究组提供了同一测量指标的前后数据,则进行荟萃分析。结果显示,积极课间休息对注意力成果(即准确性、注意力集中、抑制和持续注意力)有一些积极的急性和慢性影响,尤其是对选择性注意力。然而,大多数结果并不显著。纳入研究数量较少及其设计的异质性是本研究的主要局限性。虽然结果并未明确指出积极课间休息的积极作用,但也不会损害学生的注意力。文中讨论了积极课间休息的强度和领导者的关键作用。INPLASY注册号:202110054。