Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Windsor, Windsor, ON N9B 3P4, Canada.
Department of Chemistry, Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS B3H 4R2, Canada.
Sensors (Basel). 2021 May 14;21(10):3423. doi: 10.3390/s21103423.
This work is a comprehensive review of sensing materials, which interact with several target gases pertinent to agricultural monitoring applications. Sensing materials which interact with carbon dioxide, water vapor (relative humidity), hydrogen sulfide, ethylene and ethanol are the focus of this work. Performance characteristics such as dynamic range, recovery time, operating temperature, long-term stability and method of deposition are discussed to determine the commercial viability of the sensing materials considered in this work. In addition to the sensing materials, deposition methods are considered to obtain the desired sensing material thickness based on the sensor's mechanism of operation. Various material classes including metal oxides, conductive polymers and carbon allotropes are included in this review. By implementing multiple sensing materials to detect a single target analyte, the issue of selectivity due to cross sensitivity can be mitigated. For this reason, where possible, it is desirable to utilize more than one sensing material to monitor a single target gas. Among those considered in this work, it is observed that PEDOT PSS/graphene and TiO2-coated g-C3N4 NS are best suited for CO2 detection, given their wide dynamic range and modest operating temperature. To monitor the presence of ethylene, BMIM-NTf2, SWCNTs and PtTiO2 offer a dynamic range most suitable for the application and require no active heating. Due to the wide dynamic range offered by SiO2/Si nanowires, this material is best suited for the detection of ethanol; a gas artificially introduced to prolong the shelf life of the harvested crop. Finally, among all other sensing materials investigated, it observed that both SWCNTs and CNTs/SnO2/CuO are most suitable for H2S detection in the given application.
这项工作是对与农业监测应用相关的几种目标气体相互作用的传感材料的综合回顾。本工作的重点是与二氧化碳、水蒸气(相对湿度)、硫化氢、乙烯和乙醇相互作用的传感材料。讨论了性能特征,如动态范围、恢复时间、工作温度、长期稳定性和沉积方法,以确定本工作中考虑的传感材料的商业可行性。除了传感材料外,还考虑了沉积方法,以根据传感器的工作原理获得所需的传感材料厚度。本综述包括各种材料类别,包括金属氧化物、导电聚合物和碳同素异形体。通过使用多种传感材料来检测单一目标分析物,可以减轻由于交叉灵敏度引起的选择性问题。因此,在可能的情况下,最好使用多种传感材料来监测单一目标气体。在本工作中考虑的那些中,观察到 PEDOT PSS/石墨烯和 TiO2 涂覆的 g-C3N4 NS 最适合 CO2 检测,因为它们具有宽的动态范围和适度的工作温度。为了监测乙烯的存在,BMIM-NTf2、SWCNTs 和 PtTiO2 提供了最适合该应用的动态范围,并且不需要主动加热。由于 SiO2/Si 纳米线提供的宽动态范围,这种材料最适合检测乙醇;一种人为引入的气体,以延长收获作物的保质期。最后,在所有其他研究的传感材料中,观察到 SWCNTs 和 CNTs/SnO2/CuO 最适合给定应用中的 H2S 检测。