Nam Soohyun, Jeon Sangchoon, Ash Garrett, Whittemore Robin, Vlahov David
School of Nursing, Yale University, West Haven, CT, United States.
Veterans Affairs Connecticut Healthcare System, West Haven, CT, United States.
JMIR Form Res. 2021 Jun 7;5(6):e25687. doi: 10.2196/25687.
A growing number of studies indicate that exposure to social stress, such as perceived racial discrimination, may contribute to poor health, health behaviors, and health disparities. Increased physical activity (PA) may buffer the impact of social stress resulting from racial discrimination. However, to date, data on the relationship between racial discrimination and PA have been mixed. Part of the reason is that the effect of perceived racial discrimination on PA has primarily been examined in cross-sectional studies that captured retrospective measures of perceived racial discrimination associated with individuals' current PA outcomes. The association between real-time perceived racial discrimination and PA among African Americans remains unclear.
The purpose of this study is to examine the relationship among demographic, anthropometric and clinical, and psychological factors with lifetime racial discrimination and examine the within- and between-person associations between daily real-time racial discrimination and PA outcomes (total energy expenditure, sedentary time, and moderate-to-vigorous PA patterns) measured by ecological momentary assessment (EMA) and accelerometers in healthy African Americans.
This pilot study used an intensive, observational, case-crossover design of African Americans (n=12) recruited from the community. After participants completed baseline surveys, they were asked to wear an accelerometer for 7 days to measure their PA levels. EMA was sent to participants 5 times per day for 7 days to assess daily real-time racial discrimination. Multilevel models were used to examine the within- and between-person associations of daily racial discrimination on PA.
More EMA-reported daily racial discrimination was associated with younger age (r=0.75; P=.02). Daily EMA-reported microaggression was associated with depressive symptoms (r=0.66; P=.05), past race-related events (r=0.82; P=.004), and lifetime discrimination (r=0.78; P=.01). In the within-person analyses, the day-level association of racial discrimination and sedentary time was significant (β=.30, SE 0.14; P=.03), indicating that on occasions when participants reported more racial discrimination than usual, more sedentary time was observed. Between-person associations of racial discrimination (β=-.30, SE 0.28; P=.29) or microaggression (β=-.34, SE 0.36; P=.34) with total energy expenditure were suggestive but inconclusive.
Concurrent use of EMA and accelerometers is a feasible method to examine the relationship between racial discrimination and PA in real time. Examining daily processes at the within-person level has the potential to elucidate the mechanisms of which racial discrimination may have on health and health behaviors and to guide the development of personalized interventions for increasing PA in racial ethnic minorities. Future studies with a precision health approach, incorporating within- and between-person associations, are warranted to further elucidate the effects of racial discrimination and PA.
INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT IDENTIFIER (IRRID): RR2-10.1002/nur.22068.
越来越多的研究表明,接触社会压力,如感知到的种族歧视,可能会导致健康状况不佳、健康行为问题以及健康差距。增加身体活动(PA)可能会缓冲种族歧视所带来的社会压力影响。然而,迄今为止,关于种族歧视与身体活动之间关系的数据并不一致。部分原因在于,感知到的种族歧视对身体活动的影响主要是在横断面研究中进行考察的,这些研究获取了与个体当前身体活动结果相关的感知种族歧视的回顾性测量数据。非裔美国人中实时感知到的种族歧视与身体活动之间的关联仍不明确。
本研究的目的是探讨人口统计学、人体测量学与临床因素以及心理因素与终身种族歧视之间的关系,并通过生态学瞬时评估(EMA)和加速度计测量,研究健康非裔美国人中日常实时种族歧视与身体活动结果(总能量消耗、久坐时间以及中等至剧烈身体活动模式)之间的个体内和个体间关联。
这项试点研究采用了密集的观察性病例交叉设计,从社区招募了12名非裔美国人。参与者完成基线调查后,被要求佩戴加速度计7天以测量其身体活动水平。EMA每天向参与者发送5次,持续7天,以评估日常实时种族歧视情况。采用多层次模型来研究日常种族歧视与身体活动之间的个体内和个体间关联。
EMA报告的更多日常种族歧视与较年轻的年龄相关(r = 0.75;P = 0.02)。EMA报告的日常微侵犯与抑郁症状(r = 0.66;P = 0.05)、过去与种族相关的事件(r = 0.82;P = 0.004)以及终身歧视(r = 0.78;P = 0.01)相关。在个体内分析中,种族歧视与久坐时间的日水平关联显著(β = 0.30,标准误0.14;P = 0.03),这表明当参与者报告的种族歧视比平时更多时,观察到的久坐时间会更长。种族歧视(β = -0.30,标准误0.28;P = 0.29)或微侵犯(β = -0.34,标准误0.36;P = 0.34)与总能量消耗之间的个体间关联具有提示性,但无定论。
同时使用EMA和加速度计是实时研究种族歧视与身体活动之间关系的可行方法。在个体水平上研究日常过程有可能阐明种族歧视可能对健康和健康行为产生影响的机制,并指导制定针对增加少数族裔身体活动的个性化干预措施。未来采用精准健康方法、纳入个体内和个体间关联的研究,有必要进一步阐明种族歧视与身体活动的影响。
国际注册报告标识符(IRRID):RR2 - 10.1002/nur.22068。