Comerford Kevin B, Miller Gregory D, Boileau Amy C, Masiello Schuette Stephanie N, Giddens Janice C, Brown Katie A
California Dairy Research Foundation, Davis, CA, United States.
National Dairy Council, Rosemont, IL, United States.
Front Nutr. 2021 May 25;8:671999. doi: 10.3389/fnut.2021.671999. eCollection 2021.
At present, there are ~100 countries with national food-based dietary guidelines. While the intent of these guidelines is to inform national-level dietary recommendations, they also tie into global health and sustainable development initiatives, since diet and nutrition are linked to outcomes for all 17 United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. Therefore, key messaging in food-based dietary guidelines plays an important role in both national and global health efforts. However, this type of national-level dietary guidance is not standardized and varies considerably from country to country, and from food group to food group. The main objective of this review is to provide a novel look at dairy food group messaging within global food-based dietary guidelines, focusing specifically on nutrient-based and health-based messaging. Dairy-based messaging from 94 national food-based dietary guidelines was reviewed and grouped by region, with an emphasis on messaging regarding dairy's contribution to nutrients of public health concern for both underconsumption and overconsumption. The results showed that most nutrient-based dairy messaging relating to underconsumption was focused on calcium, followed by vitamin D, iodine, potassium, and protein; whereas messaging related to overconsumption was focused on saturated fat, added sugars, and salt. Health-based messaging specific to dairy food intake typically coalesced around three types of health outcomes: (1) bone, teeth, and muscle, (2) cardiometabolic, and (3) gut and immune. Although a fundamental concept of food-based dietary guidelines is to provide dietary guidance in a manner that is both "food-based," and in the context of "dietary" patterns, most food-based dietary guidelines still express the health value of dairy foods (and potentially other foods groups) solely in terms of their nutrient content - and often times only in the context of a single nutrient (e.g., calcium).
目前,约有100个国家制定了基于食物的国家膳食指南。虽然这些指南的目的是为国家层面的膳食建议提供信息,但它们也与全球健康和可持续发展倡议相关联,因为饮食和营养与联合国所有17个可持续发展目标的成果都有关联。因此,基于食物的膳食指南中的关键信息在国家和全球健康努力中都发挥着重要作用。然而,这种国家层面的膳食指导并不标准化,国与国之间以及不同食物类别之间差异很大。本综述的主要目的是从一个全新的视角审视全球基于食物的膳食指南中关于乳制品类别的信息,特别关注基于营养素和基于健康的信息。我们对94份基于食物的国家膳食指南中有关乳制品的信息进行了审查,并按地区进行了分类,重点关注乳制品对公共卫生关注的营养素摄入不足和过量情况的贡献相关信息。结果表明,大多数与摄入不足相关的基于营养素的乳制品信息都集中在钙上,其次是维生素D、碘、钾和蛋白质;而与摄入过量相关的信息则集中在饱和脂肪、添加糖和盐上。关于乳制品摄入的基于健康的信息通常围绕三种健康结果展开:(1)骨骼、牙齿和肌肉,(2)心脏代谢,(3)肠道和免疫。虽然基于食物的膳食指南的一个基本概念是以“基于食物”的方式并在“膳食”模式的背景下提供膳食指导,但大多数基于食物的膳食指南仍然仅根据乳制品(以及其他潜在食物类别)的营养成分来表达其健康价值——而且通常仅在单一营养素(如钙)的背景下。