de Matos Brenda Thaynne Lima, Buchaim Daniela Vieira, Pomini Karina Torres, Barbalho Sandra Maria, Guiguer Elen Landgraf, Reis Carlos Henrique Bertoni, Bueno Cleuber Rodrigo de Souza, Cunha Marcelo Rodrigues da, Pereira Eliana de Souza Bastos Mazuqueli, Buchaim Rogerio Leone
Department of Biological Sciences, Bauru School of Dentistry (FOB/USP), University of São Paulo, Bauru 17012-901, SP, Brazil.
Postgraduate Program in Structural and Functional Interactions in Rehabilitation, Postgraduate Department, University of Marilia (UNIMAR), Marília 17525-902, SP, Brazil.
Life (Basel). 2021 Jun 18;11(6):580. doi: 10.3390/life11060580.
COVID-19 is a viral disease characterized as a pandemic by the World Health Organization in March 2020. Since then, researchers from all over the world have been looking for ways to fight this disease. Many cases of complications arise from insufficient immune responses due to low immunity, with intense release of pro-inflammatory cytokines that can damage the structure of organs such as the lung. Thus, the hypothesis arises that photobiomodulation therapy (PBMT) with the use of a low-level laser (LLLT) may be an ally approach to patients with COVID-19 since it is effective for increasing immunity, helping tissue repair, and reducing pro-inflammatory cytokines. This systematic review was performed with the use of PubMed/MEDLINE, Web of Science, Scopus and Google Scholar databases with the following keywords: "low-level laser therapy OR photobiomodulation therapy AND COVID-19". The inclusion criteria were complete articles published from January 2020 to January 2021 in English. The exclusion criteria were other languages, editorials, reviews, brief communications, letters to the editor, comments, conference abstracts, and articles that did not provide the full text. The bibliographic search found 18 articles in the Pubmed/MEDLINE database, 118 articles on the Web of Science, 23 articles on Scopus, and 853 articles on Google Scholar. Ten articles were included for qualitative synthesis, of which four commentary articles discussed the pathogenesis and the effect of PBMT in COVID-19. Two in vitro and lab experiments showed the effect of PBMT on prevention of thrombosis and positive results in wound healing during viral infection, using the intravascular irradiation (ILIB) associated with Phthalomethyl D. Two case reports showed PBMT improved the respiratory indexes, radiological findings, and inflammatory markers in severe COVID-19 patients. One case series reported the clinical improvement after PBMT on 14 acute COVID-19 patients, rehabilitation on 24 patients, and as a preventive treatment on 70 people. One clinical trial of 30 patients with severe COVID-19 who require invasive mechanical ventilation, showed PBMT-static magnetic field was not statistically different from placebo for the length of stay in the Intensive Care Unit, but improved diaphragm muscle function and ventilation and decreased the inflammatory markers. This review suggests that PBMT may have a positive role in treatment of COVID-19. Still, the necessity for more clinical trials remains in this field and there is not sufficient research evidence regarding the effects of PBMT and COVID-19 disease, and there is a large gap.
2019年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)是一种病毒性疾病,2020年3月被世界卫生组织列为大流行病。自那时以来,世界各地的研究人员一直在寻找对抗这种疾病的方法。许多并发症病例是由于免疫力低下导致免疫反应不足引起的,促炎细胞因子大量释放,可能会损害肺部等器官的结构。因此,有人提出假说,使用低强度激光(LLLT)的光生物调节疗法(PBMT)可能是COVID-19患者的一种辅助治疗方法,因为它对增强免疫力、帮助组织修复和减少促炎细胞因子有效。本系统评价使用PubMed/MEDLINE、科学网、Scopus和谷歌学术数据库进行,关键词如下:“低强度激光疗法或光生物调节疗法以及COVID-19”。纳入标准为2020年1月至2021年1月以英文发表的完整文章。排除标准为其他语言、社论、综述、简短通讯、给编辑的信、评论、会议摘要以及未提供全文的文章。文献检索在PubMed/MEDLINE数据库中找到18篇文章,在科学网上找到118篇文章,在Scopus上找到23篇文章,在谷歌学术上找到853篇文章。纳入10篇文章进行定性综合分析,其中4篇评论文章讨论了PBMT在COVID-19中的发病机制和作用。两项体外和实验室实验显示了PBMT在预防血栓形成方面的作用,以及在病毒感染期间使用与邻苯二甲酰甲基D相关的血管内照射(ILIB)在伤口愈合方面的阳性结果。两项病例报告显示PBMT改善了重症COVID-19患者的呼吸指标、影像学表现和炎症标志物。一项病例系列报告了PBMT对14例急性COVID-19患者进行治疗、对24例患者进行康复治疗以及对70人进行预防性治疗后的临床改善情况。一项针对30例需要有创机械通气的重症COVID-19患者的临床试验显示,PBMT-静磁场在重症监护病房的住院时间方面与安慰剂相比无统计学差异,但改善了膈肌功能和通气,并降低了炎症标志物。本综述表明,PBMT可能在COVID-19的治疗中发挥积极作用。不过,该领域仍需要更多的临床试验,而且关于PBMT对COVID-19疾病影响的研究证据不足,存在很大差距。