Cohn Institute for History and Philosophy of Science and Ideas, Humanities Faculty, Tel Aviv University, Ramat Aviv, 6997801, Tel Aviv, Israel.
Hist Philos Life Sci. 2021 Aug 9;43(3):99. doi: 10.1007/s40656-021-00454-y.
Both concepts of the holobiont and the immune system are at the heart of an ongoing scientific and philosophical examination concerning questions of the organism's individuality and identity as well as the relations between organisms and their environment. Examining the holobiont, the question of boundaries and individuality is challenging because it is both an assemblage of organisms with physiological cohesive aspects. I discuss the concept of immunity and the immune system function from the holobiont perspective. Because of the host-microbial close relations of codependence and interdependence, the holobiont is more often than not confused with the host, as the host is the domain in which this entity exists. I discuss the holobiont unique ecological characteristics of microbial assemblages connected to a host in a network of interactions in which the host is one of the organisms in the community but also its landscape. Therefore, I suggest viewing the holobiont as a host-ecosystem and discuss the implication of such a view on the concept of immunity and the meaning of protection. Furthermore, I show that viewing the holobiont as a host ecosystem opens the possibility of using the same ecological definition of boundaries and immunity dealing with an ecological system. Thus, the holobiont's boundaries and immunity are defined by the persistence of its complex system of interactions integrating existing and new interactions. This way of thinking presents a notion of immunity that materializes as the result of the complex interdependence relations between the different organisms composing the holobiont similar to that of an ecosystem. Taking this view further, I discuss the notion of immunogenicity that is ontologically heterogeneous with various causal explanations of the processes of tolerance and targeted immune response. Finally, I discuss the possible conceptualization of already existing and new biomedical practices.
真核生物和免疫系统的概念都是目前正在进行的科学和哲学研究的核心,这些研究涉及生物体的个体性和身份以及生物体与其环境之间的关系等问题。在研究真核生物时,由于它既是具有生理上凝聚力的生物体的集合体,也是具有边界和个体性的生物体,因此其边界和个体性的问题极具挑战性。我从真核生物的角度讨论了免疫和免疫系统功能的概念。由于宿主与微生物之间存在相互依存和相互依赖的密切关系,真核生物通常与宿主混淆,因为宿主是该实体存在的领域。我讨论了与宿主相关的微生物组合的独特生态特征,这些微生物组合以宿主为中心,形成了一个相互作用的网络,其中宿主是社区中的一个生物体,也是其所在的景观。因此,我建议将真核生物视为宿主-生态系统,并讨论这种观点对免疫概念和保护意义的影响。此外,我还表明,将真核生物视为宿主生态系统为使用相同的生态边界和免疫定义来处理生态系统开辟了可能性。因此,真核生物的边界和免疫是由其整合现有和新的相互作用的复杂系统的持续存在来定义的。这种思维方式提出了一种免疫概念,它是由构成真核生物的不同生物体之间复杂的相互依赖关系的结果,类似于生态系统的免疫概念。更进一步,我讨论了免疫原性的概念,它在本体论上是异质的,具有对耐受和靶向免疫反应过程的各种因果解释。最后,我讨论了已经存在的和新的生物医学实践的可能概念化。