North Dakota State University, School of Pharmacy, Fargo, North Dakota
University of Indianapolis, School of Nursing, Indianapolis, Indiana.
Am J Pharm Educ. 2021 Aug;85(7):8327. doi: 10.5688/ajpe8327. Epub 2021 Jan 19.
To implement and evaluate a laboratory simulation for teaching difficult patient encounter skills to pharmacy students to improve their self-assessed communication abilities and skills in the affective domain. Twelve simulation scenarios that represented difficult patient encounters in a variety of practice settings were developed. All students completed a self-assessment of their ability to communicate during difficult patient encounters before and after the simulations, and wrote a guided reflection afterward. The impact of the simulation was evaluated using quantitative and qualitative methodology. Three student cohorts were analyzed to determine whether significant change occurred in students' self-perceived communication abilities. Thematic analysis of the qualitative reflection responses was performed. Over three years, three student cohorts of third-year professional students participated in the simulations (n=236). Students self-rated their ability to communicate on a 0-100 scale. Mean self-rating of ability prior to the simulation was 57.7 (SD=15.9) and after was 79.2 (SD=15.2). This mean difference of 21.5 points equates to an approximate 20% increase in self-rated ability. Variability in self-ratings between the cohorts was not significant. Qualitative analysis revealed that the simulation identified for student areas needing further development which in turn promoted self-awareness. Students expressed that learning in the safe, formative environment provided by the simulation contributed to their professional growth and was relevant to their future practice of pharmacy. This simulation fills a gap in skills-based education, addresses the affective domain of the Accreditation Council for Pharmacy Education (ACPE) Standards, transfers easily to schools and colleges of pharmacy. This supports a call to action for pharmacy educators to provide purposeful opportunities for students to practice communicating with patients during difficult encounters.
为了向药学专业的学生教授困难患者沟通技能,并提高他们在情感领域的自我评估沟通能力和技能,我们实施并评估了一个实验室模拟课程。开发了 12 个模拟场景,代表了各种实践环境中的困难患者遭遇。所有学生在模拟前后都完成了对自己在困难患者遭遇中沟通能力的自我评估,并在之后写了一篇指导反思。使用定量和定性方法评估了模拟的效果。分析了三个学生队列,以确定学生自我感知的沟通能力是否发生了显著变化。对定性反思回答进行了主题分析。在三年的时间里,三个三年级专业学生的学生队列参加了模拟(n=236)。学生在 0-100 分的范围内自我评估沟通能力。模拟前的平均自我评估能力为 57.7(SD=15.9),模拟后为 79.2(SD=15.2)。这 21.5 分的平均差异相当于自我评估能力的约 20%的增长。队列之间的自我评分变化不显著。定性分析显示,模拟确定了学生需要进一步发展的领域,从而促进了自我意识。学生们表示,模拟提供的安全、形成性环境中的学习有助于他们的专业成长,并且与他们未来的药学实践相关。这种模拟填补了技能教育的空白,满足了药学教育认证委员会(ACPE)标准的情感领域,并且很容易转移到学校和药学院。这支持了药剂学教育者采取行动的呼吁,为学生提供在困难患者遭遇中进行沟通的实践机会。