Northern Region Persistent Organic Pollution Control (NRPOP) Laboratory, Faculty of Engineering and Applied Science, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John's A1B 3X5, Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada.
School of Computing, Queen's University, Kingston K7L 2N8, Ontario, Canada.
Environ Sci Technol. 2021 Oct 5;55(19):13400-13410. doi: 10.1021/acs.est.1c02204. Epub 2021 Sep 24.
Links between environmental conditions (e.g., meteorological factors and air quality) and COVID-19 severity have been reported worldwide. However, the existing frameworks of data analysis are insufficient or inefficient to investigate the potential causality behind the associations involving multidimensional factors and complicated interrelationships. Thus, a causal inference framework equipped with the structural causal model aided by machine learning methods was proposed and applied to examine the potential causal relationships between COVID-19 severity and 10 environmental factors (NO, O, PM2.5, PM10, SO, CO, average air temperature, atmospheric pressure, relative humidity, and wind speed) in 166 Chinese cities. The cities were grouped into three clusters based on the socio-economic features. Time-series data from these cities in each cluster were analyzed in different pandemic phases. The robustness check refuted most potential causal relationships' estimations (89 out of 90). Only one potential relationship about air temperature passed the final test with a causal effect of 0.041 under a specific cluster-phase condition. The results indicate that the environmental factors are unlikely to cause noticeable aggravation of the COVID-19 pandemic. This study also demonstrated the high value and potential of the proposed method in investigating causal problems with observational data in environmental or other fields.
环境条件(如气象因素和空气质量)与 COVID-19 严重程度之间的关系已在全球范围内得到报道。然而,现有的数据分析框架不足以或效率低下,无法研究涉及多维因素和复杂相互关系的关联背后的潜在因果关系。因此,提出了一个因果推理框架,该框架配备了机器学习方法辅助的结构因果模型,并应用于研究 COVID-19 严重程度与 10 种环境因素(NO、O、PM2.5、PM10、SO、CO、平均空气温度、大气压力、相对湿度和风速)之间的潜在因果关系在中国 166 个城市。这些城市根据社会经济特征分为三个集群。对每个集群中这些城市的时间序列数据在不同的大流行阶段进行了分析。稳健性检验反驳了大多数潜在因果关系的估计(90 个中的 89 个)。只有一个关于气温的潜在关系在特定集群-阶段条件下通过了最终测试,因果效应为 0.041。结果表明,环境因素不太可能导致 COVID-19 大流行明显恶化。本研究还展示了所提出的方法在调查环境或其他领域观测数据中的因果问题方面的高价值和潜力。