University of Bologna.
Norwegian University of Science and Technology.
Workplace Health Saf. 2022 Jan;70(1):6-16. doi: 10.1177/21650799211038499. Epub 2021 Oct 7.
Interventions tackling COVID-19 impact on health care workers' mental health would benefit from being informed by validated and integrated assessment frameworks. This study aimed to explore the fitness of integrating the Job Demands-Resources (JD-R) model and the Individual-Group-Leader-Organization (IGLO) framework to investigate the pandemic's impact on health care workers' mental health.
Qualitative data were collected via 21 semi-structured interviews with senior and middle managers and four focus groups with employees (doctors, nurses, health care assistants) from three areas (Department of Emergency, Department of Medicine, Research Institute of Neuroscience) of a large health care institution facing the first wave of COVID-19. NVivo deductive content analysis of text data was performed.
Several COVID-19-related job demands and resources were found at IGLO levels. Individual-level demands included emotional load, while resources included resilience and motivation. Group-level demands included social distancing, while resources included team support and cohesion. Leader-level demands included managers' workload, while resources included leader support. Organizational-level demands included work reorganization, while resources included mental health initiatives.
CONCLUSIONS/APPLICATION TO PRACTICE: Integrating JD-R and IGLO proved feasible, as job demands and resources could be categorized according to the individual, group, leader, and organization framework. The findings expand previous studies by filling the lack of knowledge on how job demands and resources might unfold at different workplace levels during a pandemic. Results provide unit-level evidence for designing and implementing multilevel interventions to manage health care workers' mental health during COVID-19 and future pandemics. Our findings offer occupational health practitioners a suitable approach to perform workplace mental health assessment activities.
干预措施若能以经过验证和整合的评估框架为依据,针对 COVID-19 对医护人员心理健康的影响,则将从中受益。本研究旨在探讨整合工作要求-资源(JD-R)模型和个体-群体-领导-组织(IGLO)框架来研究大流行对医护人员心理健康影响的适用性。
通过对来自三个领域(急诊部、内科、神经科学研究所)的高级和中层管理人员进行 21 次半结构化访谈以及对 4 个员工(医生、护士、医疗保健助理)焦点小组收集定性数据,对文本数据进行 NVivo 演绎内容分析。
在 IGLO 层面发现了一些与 COVID-19 相关的工作要求和资源。个体层面的要求包括情绪负担,而资源包括适应力和动机。群体层面的要求包括社交距离,而资源包括团队支持和凝聚力。领导层面的要求包括经理的工作量,而资源包括领导支持。组织层面的要求包括工作重组,而资源包括心理健康计划。
结论/对实践的应用:整合 JD-R 和 IGLO 是可行的,因为可以根据个体、群体、领导和组织框架对工作要求和资源进行分类。研究结果通过填补在大流行期间不同工作场所层面上工作要求和资源可能如何展开的知识空白,扩展了以往的研究。结果为在 COVID-19 和未来大流行期间设计和实施多层次干预措施以管理医护人员心理健康提供了单位层面的证据。我们的研究结果为职业健康从业者提供了一种合适的方法来进行工作场所心理健康评估活动。