Postgraduate Program of Basic and Applied Immunology, Department of Medicine, Ribeirão Preto Medical School, University of São Paulo, Ribeirão Preto, Brazil.
Division of Endocrinology, Metabolism, and Diabetes, Department of Medicine, Aurora, Colorado, USA.
Thyroid. 2022 Feb;32(2):153-163. doi: 10.1089/thy.2021.0371. Epub 2022 Jan 12.
Combination therapy with lenvatinib plus programmed death-1 (PD-1) immune checkpoint blockades (ICBs) is under investigation in many solid tumors, including thyroid cancer. Lenvatinib is known to reduce angiogenesis and may overturn the immunosuppressive effects of vascular endothelial growth factor in the tumor microenvironment. Previous studies investigating the effects of VEGF receptor inhibition on the immune response were performed in rapidly growing tumor models where immune equilibrium is not established before treatment. We hypothesize that physiologically relevant preclinical models are necessary to define mechanisms of resistance to immune-targeted combination therapies. We utilized the TPO-CreER//Trp53 inducible transgenic model of advanced thyroid cancer to investigate lenvatinib treatment in the context of an anti-PD-1 ICB. Following tumor establishment, 3.5 months postinduction, mice were treated with high- (10 mg/kg) or low-dose (2 mg/kg) lenvatinib, anti-PD-1, or combination of lenvatinib with anti-PD-1. Tumor volume and lung metastases were assessed in each group. Immune infiltrate was characterized by flow cytometry and immunohistochemistry, and TCRß sequencing was performed to further investigate the T cell response. Both low- and high-dose lenvatinib reduced tumor volume, while anti-PD-1 had no effect, alone or in combination. Although both low- and high-dose lenvatinib reduced vascular density, low-dose lenvatinib was superior in controlling tumor size. Lung metastases and survival were not improved with therapy despite the effects of lenvatinib on primary tumor size. Low-dose lenvatinib treatment led to a subtle reduction in the dominant Ly6GCD11b myeloid cell population and was associated with increased CD4 T cell infiltrate and enrichment in 4-1BB and granzyme B CD4 T cells and FoxP3 regulatory T cells. Polyclonal T cell expansion was evident in the majority of mice, suggesting that a tumor-specific T cell response was generated. The effects of lenvatinib on the immune response were most pronounced in mice treated with low-dose lenvatinib, suggesting that dose should be considered in clinical application. While the immune-modulating potential of lenvatinib is encouraging, alterations in the immune milieu and T cell activation status were insufficient to sustain durable tumor regression, even with added anti-PD-1. Additional studies are necessary to develop more effective combination approaches in low-mutation burden tumors, such as thyroid cancer.
仑伐替尼联合程序性死亡受体-1(PD-1)免疫检查点抑制剂(ICBs)在包括甲状腺癌在内的许多实体瘤中的联合治疗正在研究中。仑伐替尼已知可减少血管生成,并可能逆转肿瘤微环境中血管内皮生长因子的免疫抑制作用。之前研究 VEGF 受体抑制对免疫反应影响的研究是在快速生长的肿瘤模型中进行的,在这些模型中,治疗前免疫平衡尚未建立。我们假设,需要使用生理相关的临床前模型来确定对免疫靶向联合治疗产生耐药的机制。
我们利用 TPO-CreER//Trp53 诱导的晚期甲状腺癌转基因模型,研究仑伐替尼治疗与抗 PD-1 ICB 联合应用的情况。在诱导后 3.5 个月肿瘤建立后,用高(10mg/kg)或低(2mg/kg)剂量仑伐替尼、抗 PD-1 或仑伐替尼联合抗 PD-1 治疗各组小鼠。评估每组的肿瘤体积和肺转移。通过流式细胞术和免疫组织化学对免疫浸润进行特征分析,并进行 TCRβ 测序以进一步研究 T 细胞反应。
低剂量和高剂量仑伐替尼均能降低肿瘤体积,而抗 PD-1 单独或联合应用均无作用。虽然低剂量和高剂量仑伐替尼均能降低血管密度,但低剂量仑伐替尼在控制肿瘤大小方面更优。尽管仑伐替尼对原发肿瘤大小有影响,但治疗并未改善肺转移和生存率。低剂量仑伐替尼治疗导致主导 Ly6GCD11b 髓样细胞群轻微减少,并与 CD4 T 细胞浸润增加以及 4-1BB 和颗粒酶 B CD4 T 细胞和 FoxP3 调节性 T 细胞富集相关。大多数小鼠中均出现多克隆 T 细胞扩增,表明产生了肿瘤特异性 T 细胞反应。
仑伐替尼对免疫反应的影响在接受低剂量仑伐替尼治疗的小鼠中最为明显,提示在临床应用中应考虑剂量。虽然仑伐替尼的免疫调节潜力令人鼓舞,但免疫微环境和 T 细胞激活状态的改变不足以维持持久的肿瘤消退,即使联合应用抗 PD-1。需要进一步研究以开发在低突变负荷肿瘤(如甲状腺癌)中更有效的联合治疗方法。