Austin Judith, Drossaert Constance H C, Sanderman Robbert, Schroevers Maya J, Bohlmeijer Ernst T
Department of Psychology, Health and Technology, Faculty of Behavioural, Management and Social Sciences, University of Twente, Enschede, Netherlands.
Department of Health Psychology, University Medical Center Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands.
Front Psychol. 2021 Oct 13;12:737725. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.737725. eCollection 2021.
Self-criticism is a self-condemning and self-compassion a supportive style of self-to-self relating. These concepts have increasingly been studied in people with cancer, but mainly with quantitative studies. This study is the first to explore how adult cancer patients experience self-criticism and self-compassion in the context of their illness. A multimethod qualitative study design was used, combining individual and group semi-structured interviews. Participants were 26 people with cancer who familiarized themselves with the topic by doing various self-compassion exercises for 2 weeks prior to the interview. Individual and group interviews were analyzed together using thematic analysis. Four themes regarding self-criticism were identified: (1) being harsh or strict with yourself, (2) feeling guilty or angry, (3) feeling useless or like a burden, (4) feeling ashamed and not wanting to show weakness. Six themes regarding self-compassion were identified: (1) being mild to yourself, (2) guarding your boundaries, (3) accepting the illness and limitations, (4) maintaining a positive perspective, (5) connecting to others, and (6) taking responsibility for your health. Our findings offer insights into practical and daily life experiences of self-criticism and self-compassion of people with cancer, which can aid the further development of theory, scales and interventions.
自我批评是一种自我谴责,而自我同情是一种自我与自我之间相互支持的方式。这些概念在癌症患者中得到了越来越多的研究,但主要是通过定量研究。本研究首次探讨成年癌症患者在患病背景下如何体验自我批评和自我同情。采用了多方法定性研究设计,结合了个体和小组半结构化访谈。参与者为26名癌症患者,他们在访谈前通过进行各种自我同情练习,为期2周,来熟悉该主题。使用主题分析法对个体和小组访谈进行了综合分析。确定了关于自我批评的四个主题:(1)对自己苛刻或严格;(2)感到内疚或愤怒;(3)觉得自己无用或像个负担;(4)感到羞耻且不想表现出软弱。确定了关于自我同情的六个主题:(1)对自己温和;(2)坚守自己的界限;(3)接受疾病和局限;(4)保持积极的观点;(5)与他人建立联系;(6)对自己的健康负责。我们的研究结果为癌症患者自我批评和自我同情的实际和日常生活体验提供了见解,这有助于理论、量表和干预措施的进一步发展。