Department of Biological Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, AL 36849.
Biology and Environmental Sciences, Auburn University at Montgomery, Montgomery, AL 36117.
CBE Life Sci Educ. 2021 Dec;20(4):ar67. doi: 10.1187/cbe.21-04-0100.
While science has profound social impacts, we often teach biology as removed from societally debated issues. Here, we address this gap in biology education through the implementation of novel materials that promote ideological awareness (IA). Using mixed-method analyses, we explore students' perceptions of the relationship between science and society, as well as their attitudes toward and knowledge of IA in biology. We found students that received the IA curriculum reported relationships between science and society that aligned with the IA activities, such as providing solutions to societal problems and combating misinformation. Additionally, we discovered a preference for IA materials over a traditional curriculum, with persons excluded because of their ethnicity and race (PEERs) reporting greater approval than non-PEERs. Although we found that the IA curriculum did not result in significant gains in science identity, engagement in biology, or science community values, we did find that students gained awareness of IA topics through a task in which they named as many scientists as possible. Specifically, IA students displayed a 300% increase in the frequency of named scientists from minoritized backgrounds compared with the traditionally taught students. We encourage instructors to incorporate IA materials into their curricula as we move toward more diverse, equitable, and inclusive teaching practices.
虽然科学对社会有深远的影响,但我们通常将生物学教学与社会争议问题隔离开来。在这里,我们通过实施新的教材来弥补生物学教育中的这一空白,这些教材能够促进学生的意识形态意识(IA)。我们使用混合方法分析,探讨了学生对科学与社会之间关系的看法,以及他们对生物学中意识形态意识的态度和知识。我们发现,接受意识形态意识课程的学生报告的科学与社会之间的关系与意识形态意识活动相符,例如为社会问题提供解决方案和打击错误信息。此外,我们发现学生更喜欢意识形态意识教材而不是传统教材,其中因种族和民族而被排斥的人(PEERs)比非 PEERs 更认可这种教材。尽管我们发现意识形态意识课程并没有导致学生在科学认同、生物学参与或科学社区价值观方面有显著的提高,但我们确实发现,学生通过一项尽可能多地列举科学家的任务,对意识形态意识主题有了更多的认识。具体来说,与传统教学的学生相比,意识形态意识课程的学生列出的少数族裔背景的科学家人数增加了 300%。我们鼓励教师在向更多元化、公平和包容的教学实践迈进的过程中,将意识形态意识教材纳入课程。