SUNY Downstate School of Public Health, Brooklyn, NY, USA.
NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, Queens, NY, USA.
J Urban Health. 2021 Dec;98(6):727-741. doi: 10.1007/s11524-021-00583-6. Epub 2021 Nov 22.
Communities marginalized because of racism, heterosexism, and other systems of oppression have a history of being aggressively policed, and in those contexts, researchers have observed associations between a range of negative experiences with police and poor physical, mental, and behavioral health outcomes. However, past studies have been limited in that experiences of police contacts were aggregated at the neighborhood level and, if police contacts were self-reported, the sample was not representative. To address these limitations, we employed NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene 2017 Social Determinants of Health Survey (n = 2335) data to examine the associations of self-reported police contacts and discrimination by police and the courts with measures of physical (poor physical health), mental (poor mental health, serious psychological distress), and behavioral health (binge drinking). Residents marginalized because of racial, ethnic, and sexual minority status were more likely to be stopped, searched, or questioned by the police; threatened or abused by the police; and discriminated against by the police or in the courts; those experiences were associated with poor physical, mental, and behavioral health outcomes. The associations between experiences with police and poor health outcomes were strongest among Black residents and residents aged 25-44. Our findings suggest that the health of NYC residents who have had exposure to police and experienced discrimination by the police and courts is poorer than those who have not, and build on a growing body of evidence that aggressive policing practices have implications for public health.
由于种族主义、异性恋歧视和其他压迫制度而处于社会边缘地位的社区一直受到警察的积极监管,在这些情况下,研究人员观察到了一系列与警察接触的负面经历与身体、心理和行为健康不良结果之间的关联。然而,过去的研究存在局限性,因为警察接触的经历是在社区层面上进行汇总的,如果警察接触是自我报告的,那么样本就没有代表性。为了解决这些限制,我们利用纽约市健康与心理卫生部 2017 年社会决定因素健康调查(n=2335)的数据,研究了自我报告的警察接触和警察与法院的歧视与身体(身体不健康)、心理(心理健康不佳、严重心理困扰)和行为健康(狂饮)测量指标之间的关联。由于种族、民族和性少数群体地位而处于社会边缘地位的居民更有可能被警察拦截、搜查或盘问;受到警察的威胁或虐待;以及受到警察或法院的歧视;这些经历与身体、心理和行为健康不良结果有关。在黑人居民和 25-44 岁的居民中,警察接触经历与健康不良结果之间的关联最强。我们的研究结果表明,接触过警察并经历过警察和法院歧视的纽约市居民的健康状况比没有接触过的居民更差,这进一步证明了积极的警务实践对公共健康的影响。