Lai Chia-Ho, Hsieh Shu-Kai, Lee Chia-Lin, Su Lily I-Wen, Liu Te-Hsin, Lu Chia-Rung, Tsai I-Ni, Chou Tai-Li
Department of Psychology, New York University, New York, NY, United States.
Department of Psychology, National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan.
Front Psychol. 2021 Nov 18;12:781304. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.781304. eCollection 2021.
The present study aimed to investigate the neural mechanism underlying semantic processing in Mandarin Chinese adult learners, focusing on the learners who were Indo-European language speakers with advanced levels of proficiency in Mandarin Chinese. We used functional magnetic resonance imaging technique and a semantic judgment task to test 24 Mandarin Chinese adult learners (L2 group) and 26 Mandarin Chinese adult native speakers (L1 group) as a control group. In the task, participants were asked to indicate whether two-character pairs were related in meaning. Compared to the L1 group, the L2 group had greater activation in the bilateral occipital regions, including the fusiform gyrus and middle occipital gyrus, as well as the right superior parietal lobule. On the other hand, less activation in the bilateral temporal regions was found in the L2 group relative to the L1 group. Correlation analysis further revealed that, within the L2 group, increased activation in the left middle temporal gyrus/superior temporal gyrus (M/STG, BA 21) was correlated with higher accuracy in the semantic judgment task as well as better scores in the two vocabulary tests, the Assessment of Chinese character list for grade 3 to grade 9 (A39) and the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised. In addition, functional connectivity analysis showed that connectivity strength between the left fusiform gyrus and left ventral inferior frontal gyrus (IFG, BA 47) was modulated by the accuracy in the semantic judgment task in the L1 group. By contrast, this modulation effect was weaker in the L2 group. Taken together, our study suggests that Mandarin Chinese adult learners rely on greater recruitment of the bilateral occipital regions to process orthographic information to access the meaning of Chinese characters. Also, our correlation results provide convergent evidence that the left M/STG (BA 21) plays a crucial role in the storage of semantic knowledge for readers to access to conceptual information. Moreover, the connectivity results indicate that the left ventral pathway (left fusiform gyrus-left ventral IFG) is associated with orthographic-semantic processing in Mandarin Chinese. However, this semantic-related ventral pathway might require more time and language experience to be developed, especially for the late adult learners of Mandarin Chinese.
本研究旨在探究汉语成年学习者语义加工背后的神经机制,重点关注以印欧语系为母语且汉语水平较高的学习者。我们使用功能磁共振成像技术和语义判断任务,对24名汉语成年学习者(第二语言组)和26名以汉语为母语的成年汉语使用者(第一语言组)作为对照组进行测试。在任务中,参与者被要求指出双字对在意义上是否相关。与第一语言组相比,第二语言组在双侧枕叶区域,包括梭状回和枕中回,以及右侧顶上小叶有更大的激活。另一方面,相对于第一语言组,第二语言组在双侧颞叶区域的激活较少。相关分析进一步表明,在第二语言组中,左侧颞中回/颞上回(M/STG,BA 21)激活增加与语义判断任务中的更高准确性以及两项词汇测试(三年级至九年级汉字评估清单(A39)和皮博迪图片词汇测试修订版)中的更好成绩相关。此外,功能连接分析表明,第一语言组中左侧梭状回和左侧腹侧额下回(IFG,BA 47)之间的连接强度受语义判断任务准确性的调节。相比之下,这种调节效应在第二语言组中较弱。综上所述,我们的研究表明,汉语成年学习者在处理正字法信息以获取汉字意义时依赖于双侧枕叶区域的更大激活。此外,我们的相关结果提供了一致的证据,即左侧M/STG(BA 21)在读者获取概念信息的语义知识存储中起着关键作用。此外,连接结果表明,左侧腹侧通路(左侧梭状回 - 左侧腹侧IFG)与汉语正字法 - 语义加工相关。然而,这种与语义相关的腹侧通路可能需要更多时间和语言经验来发展,特别是对于汉语成年晚期学习者。