Magdas Dana Alina, Cristea Gabriela, Pîrnau Adrian, Feher Ioana, Hategan Ariana Raluca, Dehelean Adriana
National Institute for Research and Development of Isotopic and Molecular Technologies, P.O. Box 700, 400293 Cluj-Napoca, Romania.
Foods. 2021 Dec 4;10(12):3000. doi: 10.3390/foods10123000.
The potential association between stable isotope ratios of light elements and mineral content, in conjunction with unsupervised and supervised statistical methods, for differentiation of spirits, with respect to some previously defined criteria, is reviewed in this work. Thus, based on linear discriminant analysis (LDA), it was possible to differentiate the geographical origin of distillates in a percentage of 96.2% for the initial validation, and the cross-validation step of the method returned 84.6% of correctly classified samples. An excellent separation was also obtained for the differentiation of spirits producers, 100% in initial classification, and 95.7% in cross-validation, respectively. For the varietal recognition, the best differentiation was achieved for apricot and pear distillates, a 100% discrimination being obtained in both classifications (initial and cross-validation). Good classification percentages were also obtained for plum and apple distillates, where models with 88.2% and 82.4% in initial and cross-validation, respectively, were achieved for plum differentiation. A similar value in the cross-validation procedure was reached for the apple spirits. The lowest classification percent was obtained for quince distillates (76.5% in initial classification followed by 70.4% in cross-validation). Our results have high practical importance, especially for trademark recognition, taking into account that fruit distillates are high-value commodities; therefore, the temptation of "fraud", i.e., by passing regular distillates as branded ones, could occur.
本文综述了轻元素稳定同位素比值与矿物质含量之间的潜在关联,并结合无监督和有监督统计方法,依据一些先前定义的标准对烈酒进行区分。因此,基于线性判别分析(LDA),在初始验证中能够以96.2%的准确率区分馏出物的地理来源,该方法的交叉验证步骤返回了84.6%正确分类的样本。在区分烈酒生产商方面也获得了出色的分离效果,初始分类和交叉验证的准确率分别为100%和95.7%。对于品种识别,杏仁和梨馏出物的区分效果最佳,在初始分类和交叉验证中均实现了100%的判别率。李子和苹果馏出物也获得了较好的分类百分比,在李子区分的初始和交叉验证模型中,准确率分别为88.2%和82.4%。苹果烈酒在交叉验证过程中达到了类似的值。榅桲馏出物的分类百分比最低(初始分类为76.5%,交叉验证为70.4%)。考虑到水果馏出物是高价值商品,我们的结果具有很高的实际重要性,特别是对于商标识别;因此,可能会出现“欺诈”行为,即把普通馏出物冒充为品牌馏出物。