Li Hongwan, Shankar Sripriya Nannu, Witanachchi Chiran T, Lednicky John A, Loeb Julia C, Alam Md Mahbubul, Fan Z Hugh, Mohamed Karim, Eiguren-Fernandez Arantzazu, Wu Chang-Yu
Department of Environmental Engineering Sciences, University of Florida, USA.
Department of Environmental and Global Health, University of Florida, USA.
Aerosol Air Qual Res. 2021 Nov;21(11). doi: 10.4209/aaqr.210106. Epub 2021 Sep 2.
Fitness centers are considered high risk for SARS-CoV-2 transmission due to their high human occupancy and the type of activity taking place in them, especially when individuals pre-symptomatic or asymptomatic for COVID-19 exercise in the facilities. In this study, air (N=21) and surface (N=8) samples were collected at a fitness center through five sampling events from August to November 2020 after the reopening restrictions were lifted in Florida. The total attendance was ~2500 patrons during our air and environmental sampling work. Air samples were collected using stationary and personal bioaerosol samplers. Moistened flocked nylon swabs were used to collect samples from high-touch surfaces. We did not detect SARS-CoV-2 by rRT-PCR analyses in any air or surface sample. A simplified infection risk model based on the Wells-Riley equation predicts that the probability of infection in this fitness center was 1.77% following its ventilation system upgrades based on CDC guidelines, and that risk was further reduced to 0.89% when patrons used face masks. Our model also predicts that a combination of high ventilation, minimal air recirculation, air filtration, and UV sterilization of recirculated air reduced the infection risk up to 94% compared to poorly ventilated facilities. Amongst these measures, high ventilation with outdoor air is most critical in reducing the airborne transmission of SARS-CoV-2. For buildings that cannot avoid air recirculation due to energy costs, the use of high filtration and/or air disinfection devices are alternatives to reducing the probability of acquiring SARS-CoV-2 through inhalation exposure. In contrast to the perceived ranking of high risk, the infection risk in fitness centers that follow CDC reopening guidance, including implementation of engineering and administrative controls, and use of personal protective equipment, can be low, and these facilities can offer a relatively safe venue for patrons to exercise.
由于健身中心人员高度密集以及其内部进行的活动类型,尤其是当新冠病毒感染者处于症状出现前或无症状状态时在健身设施中锻炼,所以健身中心被认为是新冠病毒传播的高风险场所。在本研究中,2020年8月至11月佛罗里达州解除重新开放限制后,通过五次采样活动在一家健身中心采集了空气样本(N = 21)和表面样本(N = 8)。在我们进行空气和环境采样工作期间,该健身中心的总客流量约为2500人次。使用固定式和个人生物气溶胶采样器采集空气样本。用湿润的植绒尼龙拭子从高频接触表面采集样本。通过逆转录-聚合酶链反应(rRT-PCR)分析,我们在任何空气或表面样本中均未检测到新冠病毒。基于韦尔斯-莱利方程的简化感染风险模型预测,按照美国疾病控制与预防中心(CDC)指南对通风系统进行升级后,该健身中心的感染概率为1.77%,而当顾客佩戴口罩时,这一风险进一步降至0.89%。我们的模型还预测,与通风不良的设施相比,高通风量、最小限度的空气再循环、空气过滤以及对再循环空气进行紫外线消毒相结合,可将感染风险降低高达94%。在这些措施中,引入室外空气进行高通风量换气对于减少新冠病毒的空气传播最为关键。对于因能源成本而无法避免空气再循环的建筑,使用高效过滤器和/或空气消毒设备是降低通过吸入暴露感染新冠病毒概率的替代方法。与人们认为的高风险等级相反,遵循CDC重新开放指南(包括实施工程和管理控制措施以及使用个人防护设备)的健身中心感染风险可能较低,这些设施可以为顾客提供一个相对安全的锻炼场所。