McGuire Joel, Kaiser Caspar, Bach-Mortensen Anders M
Happier Lives Institute, Oxford, UK.
Wellbeing Research Centre & Institute for New Economic Thinking, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Nat Hum Behav. 2022 Mar;6(3):359-370. doi: 10.1038/s41562-021-01252-z. Epub 2022 Jan 20.
Cash transfers (CTs) are increasingly recognized as a scalable intervention to alleviate financial hardship. A large body of evidence evaluates the impact of CTs on subjective well-being (SWB) and mental health (MH) in low- and middle-income countries. We undertook a systematic review, quality appraisal and meta-analysis of 45 studies examining the impact of CTs on self-reported SWB and MH outcomes, covering a sample of 116,999 individuals. After an average follow-up time of two years, we find that CTs have a small but statistically significant positive effect on both SWB (Cohen's d = 0.13, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.09, 0.18) and MH (d = 0.07, 95% CI 0.05, 0.09) among recipients. CT value, both relative to previous income and in absolute terms, is a strong predictor of the effect size. Based on this review and the large body of existing research demonstrating a positive impact of CTs on other outcomes (for example, health and income), there is evidence to suggest that CTs improve lives. To enable comparisons of the relative efficacy of CTs to improve MH and SWB, future research should meta-analyse the effects of alternative interventions in similar contexts.
现金转移支付(CTs)日益被视为一种可扩展的干预措施,以缓解经济困难。大量证据评估了现金转移支付对低收入和中等收入国家主观幸福感(SWB)和心理健康(MH)的影响。我们对45项研究进行了系统综述、质量评估和荟萃分析,这些研究考察了现金转移支付对自我报告的主观幸福感和心理健康结果的影响,涵盖了116,999名个体的样本。在平均两年的随访期后,我们发现现金转移支付对受助者的主观幸福感(科恩d值 = 0.13,95%置信区间(CI)0.09,0.18)和心理健康(d值 = 0.07,95% CI 0.05,0.09)均有微小但在统计学上显著的积极影响。现金转移支付的价值,无论是相对于以前的收入还是绝对价值,都是效应大小的有力预测指标。基于这项综述以及大量现有研究表明现金转移支付对其他结果(如健康和收入)有积极影响,有证据表明现金转移支付能改善生活。为了能够比较现金转移支付改善心理健康和主观幸福感的相对效果,未来的研究应该对类似背景下替代干预措施的效果进行荟萃分析。