Zaba Tomás, Conkle Joel, Nyawo Mara, Foote Dorothy, Myatt Mark
United Nations Children's Fund, 1440 Zimbabwe Avenue, Maputo, Mozambique.
United Nations Children's Fund, 1st Floor UN House, 38-44 Stein St, Klein Windhoek, Namibia.
BMC Nutr. 2022 Feb 18;8(1):15. doi: 10.1186/s40795-022-00508-9.
In the past it was believed that wasting and stunting were independent of each other. Recent work has shown that they can occur concurrently in a child and that increases considerably the risk of mortality. Concurrent wasting and stunting (WaSt) is currently defined as WHZ < -2 AND HAZ < -2. Wasting is measured by WHZ and MUAC and evidence shows that they tend to identify different sets of children. Our study aimed to look at the effect of adding MUAC on the prevalence and burden of WaSt, and to assess diagnosis of WaSt with a single measurement.
We analyzed population-based anthropometric surveys from 37 districts in Mozambique conducted by the Government of Mozambique between 2017 and 2019. We proposed a new case-definition for WaSt that includes MUAC in acknowledgement of the different children with wasting diagnosed by WHZ and MUAC. We estimated how many WaSt cases are eligible to be included in the existing treatment program in Mozambique by calculating the True Positive and False Positive Values of WaSt using our proposed case-definition against the wasting admission criteria. AUC of ROC curves used for MUAC and WAZ and optimal cut-offs were determined using Youden's Index.
Including MUAC in the concurrent WaSt case-definition identified more children with WaSt compared to the original case-definition and more younger children and girls were identified. Using both MUAC and WHZ and enrolling severe and moderate wasting is already picking up most of the WaSt cases: 100% in health facilities and 79.40% with MUAC mass screenings at community level. Cut-off values from the ROC curve for the proposed case-definition were MUAC ≤133 mm and WAZ ≤ 2.145 Z-scores, however, they yielded many false positive values.
WaSt case-definition should include MUAC. WaSt should commence to be reported in surveys and Mozambique should also start monitoring and treating children with WaSt. A cost-effective approach to identify all children with WaSt without adding too many false positive is needed, as well as understanding how to achieve optimal treatment outcomes within existing programs.
过去人们认为消瘦和发育迟缓是相互独立的。最近的研究表明,它们可能同时出现在一个儿童身上,这会显著增加死亡风险。目前,同时存在消瘦和发育迟缓(WaSt)的定义为身高别体重(WHZ)< -2且身高别年龄(HAZ)< -2。消瘦通过WHZ和上臂围(MUAC)来衡量,有证据表明它们往往能识别出不同的儿童群体。我们的研究旨在探讨增加MUAC对WaSt患病率和负担的影响,并评估用单一测量方法诊断WaSt的情况。
我们分析了莫桑比克政府在2017年至2019年间对莫桑比克37个地区进行的基于人群的人体测量调查。我们提出了一个新的WaSt病例定义,该定义纳入了MUAC,以认可通过WHZ和MUAC诊断出的不同消瘦儿童。我们通过使用我们提出的病例定义对照消瘦入院标准计算WaSt的真阳性和假阳性值,来估计有多少WaSt病例符合莫桑比克现有治疗项目的纳入标准。使用尤登指数确定用于MUAC和身高别体重(WAZ)的ROC曲线的AUC及最佳截断值。
与原始病例定义相比,在同时存在的WaSt病例定义中纳入MUAC能识别出更多患有WaSt的儿童,且能识别出更多的年幼儿童和女童。同时使用MUAC和WHZ并纳入重度和中度消瘦病例,已经涵盖了大部分WaSt病例:在医疗机构中为100%,在社区层面进行MUAC大规模筛查时为79.40%。所提议病例定义的ROC曲线截断值为MUAC≤133毫米且WAZ≤2.145 Z评分,然而,它们产生了许多假阳性值。
WaSt病例定义应包括MUAC。应开始在调查中报告WaSt情况,莫桑比克也应开始监测和治疗患有WaSt的儿童。需要一种经济有效的方法来识别所有患有WaSt的儿童,同时不增加过多假阳性,以及了解如何在现有项目中实现最佳治疗效果。