Nezamabadi Kasra, Sardaripour Neda, Haghi Benyamin, Forouzanfar Mohamad
IEEE Rev Biomed Eng. 2023;16:208-224. doi: 10.1109/RBME.2022.3154893. Epub 2023 Jan 5.
Electrocardiography is the gold standard technique for detecting abnormal heart conditions. Automatic detection of electrocardiogram (ECG) abnormalities helps clinicians analyze the large amount of data produced daily by cardiac monitors. As thenumber of abnormal ECG samples with cardiologist-supplied labels required to train supervised machine learning models is limited, there is a growing need for unsupervised learning methods for ECG analysis. Unsupervised learning aims to partition ECG samples into distinct abnormality classes without cardiologist-supplied labels-a process referred to as ECG clustering. In addition to abnormality detection, ECG clustering has recently discovered inter and intra-individual patterns that reveal valuable information about the whole body and mind, such as emotions, mental disorders, and metabolic levels. ECG clustering can also resolve specific challenges facing supervised learning systems, such as the imbalanced data problem, and can enhance biometric systems. While several reviews exist on supervised ECG systems, a comprehensive review of unsupervised ECG analysis techniques is still lacking. This study reviews ECG clustering techniques developed mainly in the last decade. The focus will be on recent machine learning and deep learning algorithms and their practical applications. We critically review and compare these techniques, discuss their applications and limitations, and provide future research directions. This review provides further insights into ECG clustering and presents the necessary information required to adopt the appropriate algorithm for a specific application.
心电图检查是检测心脏异常状况的金标准技术。自动检测心电图(ECG)异常有助于临床医生分析心脏监测仪每天产生的大量数据。由于训练监督式机器学习模型所需的带有心脏病专家提供标签的异常ECG样本数量有限,因此对用于ECG分析的无监督学习方法的需求日益增长。无监督学习旨在将ECG样本划分为不同的异常类别,而无需心脏病专家提供标签——这一过程称为ECG聚类。除了异常检测外,ECG聚类最近还发现了个体间和个体内的模式,这些模式揭示了有关全身和心理的有价值信息,如情绪、精神障碍和代谢水平。ECG聚类还可以解决监督学习系统面临的特定挑战,如数据不平衡问题,并可以增强生物识别系统。虽然已有几篇关于监督式ECG系统的综述,但仍缺乏对无监督ECG分析技术的全面综述。本研究综述了主要在过去十年中开发的ECG聚类技术。重点将放在最近的机器学习和深度学习算法及其实际应用上。我们对这些技术进行了批判性审查和比较,讨论了它们的应用和局限性,并提供了未来的研究方向。本综述进一步深入了解了ECG聚类,并提供了针对特定应用采用适当算法所需的必要信息。