Faculty of Health and Environment Sciences, Auckland University of Technology, Auckland, New Zealand.
Te Rōpū Whāriki, Massey University, Auckland, New Zealand.
Health Soc Care Community. 2022 Nov;30(6):e4020-e4027. doi: 10.1111/hsc.13795. Epub 2022 Mar 18.
Racism is a key modifiable determinant of health that contributes to health inequities in Aotearoa and elsewhere. Experiences of racism occur within the health sector for workers, patients and their whānau (extended family) every day. This paper uses stories of racism from nurses - reworked into vignettes - to examine the dynamics of racism to generate possible micro, meso and macro anti-racism interventions. A critical qualitative design was utilised, informed by kaupapa Māori approaches. The five vignettes in this paper were sourced from a pair of caucused focus groups with nine senior Māori (Indigenous peoples of Aotearoa) and Tauiwi (non-Māori) nurses held in Auckland Aotearoa in 2019. The vignettes were lightly edited and then critically analysed by both authors to identify sites of racism and generate ideas for anti-racism interventions. The vignettes illustrate five key themes in relation to racism. These include (i) mono-cultural practice, (ii) everyday micro-aggressions; (iii) complexity and the costs of racism, (iv) Pākehā (white settler) privilege and (v) employment discrimination. From analysing these themes, a range of evidence-based micro, meso and macro-level anti-racism interventions were derived. These ranged from engaging in reflective practice, education initiatives, monitoring, through to collective advocacy. Vignettes are a novel way to reveal sites of racism to create teachable moments and spark reflective practice and more active engagement in anti-racism interventions. When systematically analysed vignettes can be utilised to inform and refine anti-racist interventions. Being able to identify racism is essential to being able to effectively counter racism.
种族主义是健康的一个主要可改变决定因素,它导致了奥特亚罗瓦和其他地方的健康不平等。在卫生部门,工人、患者及其家属(大家庭)每天都在经历种族主义。本文使用护士的种族主义经历——改编成小插曲——来检查种族主义的动态,以产生可能的微观、中观和宏观反种族主义干预措施。本文使用了批判性定性设计,以毛利人方法为指导。本文中的五个小插曲来自于 2019 年在奥克兰奥特亚罗瓦举行的两次焦点小组会议,参与者是 9 名资深毛利(奥特亚罗瓦的土著人民)和 Tauiwi(非毛利)护士。这些小插曲经过轻微编辑,然后由两位作者进行批判性分析,以确定种族主义的地点,并提出反种族主义干预的想法。小插曲说明了与种族主义有关的五个关键主题。这些主题包括 (i) 单一文化实践、(ii) 日常微侵犯;(iii) 种族主义的复杂性和代价,(iv) Pākehā(白种定居者)特权和 (v) 就业歧视。通过分析这些主题,得出了一系列基于证据的微观、中观和宏观层面的反种族主义干预措施。这些措施包括从事反思实践、教育举措、监测,直至集体倡导。小插曲是一种揭示种族主义地点的新颖方式,可以创造教学时刻,激发反思实践,并更积极地参与反种族主义干预。当系统地分析小插曲时,可以利用它们来为反种族主义干预提供信息和改进。能够识别种族主义是有效对抗种族主义的必要条件。