Hydrotox GmbH, Bötzinger Str. 29, 79111 Freiburg, Germany.
Hydrotox GmbH, Bötzinger Str. 29, 79111 Freiburg, Germany.
Sci Total Environ. 2022 Aug 10;833:155134. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2022.155134. Epub 2022 Apr 9.
In persistence assessment enhanced ready biodegradation tests (eRBT) are aimed to close the gap between screening tests and complex simulation tests. However, only few data from these tests are available and neither guidance on the design and interpretation of eRBTs, nor suitable validity criteria have been established so far. In a practical testing programme 5 compounds with controversial degradation data have been tested in 4 test series including prolongation to 60 days and use of different inocula (activated sludge, final effluent from a STP), flask sizes, and endpoints (CO, O, DOC). The drug ibuprofen and the intermediate 4-fluorophenol were biodegraded by >60% within 28 days within a 10-day-window and therefore are considered as readily biodegradable and in conclusion fulfilling the criteria for "not persistent". The mean mineralization of the pesticide synergist piperonylbutoxide and the antioxidant octadecyl 3-(3,5-di-tert-butyl-4-hydroxyphenyl)propionate achieved 20%-50% (="potentially P"). The mineralization of the cosmetic ingredient cis-13-docosenonamide (Erucamide) was between 36%-64% after 60 days with activated sludge and 21% with the effluent from the STP. Diethylene glycol reached the pass level of 60% mineralization within 28 days in all test series without always meeting the 10-day window, and thus proved to be a suitable reference substance for eRBTs. Based on the results of the study several recommendations for the test design, the evaluation and the interpretation of eRBTs are made. However, a broader data set is required and further enhancements such as the quality and amount of the inoculum should also be considered in future research.
在持久性评估增强型可快速生物降解测试(eRBT)中,旨在缩小筛选测试和复杂模拟测试之间的差距。然而,目前可用的这些测试数据很少,既没有关于 eRBT 的设计和解释的指南,也没有合适的有效性标准。在实际测试计划中,有 5 种具有争议性降解数据的化合物在 4 个测试系列中进行了测试,包括延长至 60 天和使用不同的接种物(活性污泥、STP 的最终出水)、瓶大小和终点(CO、O、DOC)。药物布洛芬和中间产物 4-氟苯酚在 10 天的窗口内 28 天内生物降解了>60%,因此被认为是可快速生物降解的,并且符合“非持久性”的标准。农药增效剂胡椒基丁氧基和抗氧化剂十八烷基 3-(3,5-二叔丁基-4-羟基苯基)丙酸的平均矿化率达到 20%-50%(“可能 P”)。在 60 天内,化妆品成分顺式-13-二十二碳烯酰胺(Erucamide)在活性污泥中的矿化率为 36%-64%,在 STP 的出水为 21%。二甘醇在所有测试系列中在 28 天内达到 60%的矿化通过率,而并非总是符合 10 天窗口,因此被证明是 eRBT 的合适参考物质。基于该研究的结果,提出了一些关于测试设计、评估和解释 eRBT 的建议。然而,需要更广泛的数据集,并且在未来的研究中还应考虑接种物的质量和数量等进一步改进。