Department of Public Health and Health Systems, Graduate School of Medicine, Nagoya University, Nagoya 466-8550, Japan.
Graduate School of Humanities and Sociology, University of Tokyo, Tokyo 113-0033, Japan.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 Apr 9;19(8):4550. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19084550.
(1) Background: While advance care planning (ACP) provides healthcare professionals with valuable tools to meet patients' needs in a person-centered manner, several potential ethical challenges are inherent to the process. However, recent studies have largely focused on ACP practicalities such as implementation, execution, and completion rather than on the ethical challenges that clinicians routinely encounter in ACP practices. (2) Research question/aim/objectives: This study aimed to identify tips for clinicians managing ethical challenges in ACP practices. (3) Methods: It performed a brief search for all Japanese published books pertaining to ACP practice available as of January 2021 using the keywords "advance care planning (ACP)" and "autonomy" and analyze the content of nine practical ACP textbooks for clinicians. (4) Results: Two major themes capturing the essential recommendations for managing ethical challenges in ACP were ultimately identified, namely interprofessional ethics and informed consent. (5) Conclusion: The findings suggested tips for managing ethical challenges in ACP: refer to ethical frameworks for interprofessional collaboration and ethical decision making, assess decision-making capacity of family substitute decision makers and one's eligibility for the role, understand the standard process of informed consent and how to handle situations when the patient are not well informed about the diagnosis and prognosis of non-cancer illness.
(1) 背景:尽管预先医疗照护计划(advance care planning,ACP)为医疗专业人员提供了以患者为中心满足其需求的宝贵工具,但该过程中存在一些固有的潜在伦理挑战。然而,最近的研究主要集中在 ACP 的实际操作,如实施、执行和完成方面,而不是在 ACP 实践中临床医生经常遇到的伦理挑战方面。(2) 研究问题/目的/目标:本研究旨在确定临床医生处理 ACP 实践中伦理挑战的技巧。(3) 方法:它使用“advance care planning (ACP)”和“autonomy”这两个关键词,对截至 2021 年 1 月所有已出版的与 ACP 实践相关的日本书籍进行了简短的搜索,并分析了九本针对临床医生的实用 ACP 教科书的内容。(4) 结果:最终确定了两个主要主题,即跨专业伦理和知情同意,这两个主题涵盖了处理 ACP 实践中伦理挑战的基本建议。(5) 结论:研究结果提出了处理 ACP 中伦理挑战的建议:参考跨专业协作和伦理决策的伦理框架,评估替代决策者的决策能力及其对该角色的资格,了解知情同意的标准流程以及在患者对非癌症疾病的诊断和预后没有充分了解的情况下如何处理。