Dinu Monica, Pagliai Giuditta, Del Bo' Cristian, Porrini Marisa, Riso Patrizia, Serafini Mauro, Sofi Francesco, Martini Daniela, Angelino Donato
Department of Experimental and Clinical Medicine, University of Florence, Florence, Italy.
Department of Food, Environmental and Nutritional Sciences (DeFENS), University of Milan, Milan, Italy.
Front Nutr. 2022 Apr 25;9:870776. doi: 10.3389/fnut.2022.870776. eCollection 2022.
Clinical trial registration has become a valuable tool that can be used to track the status and nature of trials conducted on a specific topic. This approach has been applied to many areas of research, but less is known about the characteristics and trends over time of clinical trials focused on diet and health. The aim of this study was to analyze diet-related clinical trials registered on the National Institute of Health "ClinicalTrials.gov" web platform in the last 10 years, to list and describe their characteristics, and to identify possible gaps to be filled in the future research.
A search was performed on the ClinicalTrials.gov database. Intervention studies registered from January 2010 to December 2020, conducted on adults, with a follow-up of ≥2 weeks, evaluating the impact of different diets on all outcomes except those assessed with scales or questionnaires were considered.
At the end of the selection process, a total of 1,016 registered clinical trials were identified and included in the analysis. The most investigated dietary approaches were balanced diets ( = 381 trials), followed by those based on a modification of macronutrients ( = 288) and time-restricted feeding and intermittent fasting diets ( = 140). The main measured outcomes included anthropometric parameters and body composition (57.8%), glycemic control parameters (49.7%), lipid parameters (40.1%), inflammatory markers (29.1%), and blood pressure and/or heart rate (24.5%). A growing body of studies also focused on microbiota and host metabolism (17.8%). Most studies had a duration of less than 12 weeks (~60%), and more than 90% of studies enrolled volunteers with overweight/obesity or other diseases. Regarding aging, only 21 studies focused only on older adults.
The number of studies investigating the relationship between diet and health has increased over the years. Despite the growing interest in the topic, there are some gaps, such as the limited duration of most trials, the underrepresentation of some population groups, and the limited number of studies for some diets that, although popular in the population, lack robust scientific evidence.
临床试验注册已成为一种有价值的工具,可用于追踪针对特定主题开展的试验的状态和性质。这种方法已应用于许多研究领域,但对于专注于饮食与健康的临床试验随时间推移的特征和趋势了解较少。本研究的目的是分析过去10年在美国国立卫生研究院“ClinicalTrials.gov”网络平台上注册的与饮食相关的临床试验,列出并描述其特征,并确定未来研究中可能需要填补的空白。
在ClinicalTrials.gov数据库上进行了检索。纳入2010年1月至2020年12月注册的、针对成年人开展的、随访时间≥2周、评估不同饮食对除用量表或问卷评估之外的所有结局的影响的干预性研究。
在筛选过程结束时,共确定了1016项注册临床试验并纳入分析。研究最多的饮食方式是均衡饮食(381项试验),其次是基于宏量营养素调整的饮食(288项)以及限时进食和间歇性禁食饮食(140项)。主要测量结局包括人体测量参数和身体成分(57.8%)、血糖控制参数(49.7%)、血脂参数(40.1%)、炎症标志物(29.1%)以及血压和/或心率(24.5%)。越来越多的研究也关注微生物群与宿主代谢(17.8%)。大多数研究持续时间少于12周(约60%),超过90%的研究招募超重/肥胖或其他疾病的志愿者。关于衰老,仅有21项研究仅关注老年人。
多年来,研究饮食与健康之间关系的研究数量有所增加。尽管对该主题的兴趣日益浓厚,但仍存在一些空白,例如大多数试验持续时间有限、某些人群代表性不足,以及一些在人群中虽受欢迎但缺乏有力科学证据的饮食的研究数量有限。