Luo Tianyi, Cao Zhidong, Wang Yuejiao, Zeng Daniel, Zhang Qingpeng
State Key Laboratory of Management and Control for Complex SystemsInstitute of Automation, Chinese Academy of Sciences Beijing 100190 China.
School of Artificial IntelligenceUniversity of Chinese Academy of Sciences Beijing 100049 China.
IEEE Trans Autom Sci Eng. 2021 Sep 3;19(2):576-585. doi: 10.1109/TASE.2021.3106782. eCollection 2022 Apr.
As part of ongoing efforts to contain the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic, understanding the role of asymptomatic patients in the transmission system is essential for infection control. However, the optimal approach to risk assessment and management of asymptomatic cases remains unclear. This study proposed a Susceptible, Exposed, Infectious, No symptoms, Hospitalized and reported, Recovered, Death (SEINRHD) epidemic propagation model. The model was constructed based on epidemiological characteristics of COVID-19 in China and accounting for the heterogeneity of social contact networks. The early community outbreaks in Wuhan were reconstructed and fitted with the actual data. We used this model to assess epidemic control measures for asymptomatic cases in three dimensions. The impact of asymptomatic cases on epidemic propagation was examined based on the effective reproduction number, abnormally high transmission events, and type and structure of transmission. Management of asymptomatic cases can help flatten the infection curve. Tracing 75% of the asymptomatic cases corresponds to a 32.5% overall reduction in new cases (compared with tracing no asymptomatic cases). Regardless of population-wide measures, household transmission is higher than other types of transmission, accounting for an estimated 50% of all cases. The magnitude of tracing of asymptomatic cases is more important than the timing; when all symptomatic patients were traced, tested, and isolated in a timely manner, the overall epidemic was not sensitive to the time of implementing the measures to trace asymptomatic patients. Disease control and prevention within families should be emphasized during an epidemic. -This article addresses the urgent need to assess the risk of another COVID-19 outbreak caused by asymptomatic cases and to find the optimal, most practical approach to asymptomatic case management. Previous studies mostly focused on the clinical and statistical characteristics of asymptomatic cases; few have evaluated the impact of asymptomatic case measures using mathematical modeling at the community scale. This study proposed a Susceptible, Exposed, Infectious, No symptoms, Hospitalized and reported, Recovered, Death (SEINRHD) propagation model based on local community structures and social contact networks, according to the development characteristics and trend of COVID-19 in a Chinese community. The conclusion provides theoretical support for emergency work of relevant departments in different periods of an epidemic. In the early stages of the epidemic, timely detection and isolation of symptomatic patients should be a priority. Where there are surplus resources for epidemic prevention, the authorities should consider increasing the proportion of asymptomatic patients being traced. Epidemic prevention measures among family members should be a primary focus of attention. This combination of strategies can help reduce the rate of viral transmission and result in extinguishing the epidemic.
作为持续遏制新型冠状病毒肺炎(COVID-19)大流行工作的一部分,了解无症状感染者在传播系统中的作用对于感染控制至关重要。然而,无症状感染者风险评估和管理的最佳方法仍不明确。本研究提出了一种易感、暴露、感染、无症状、住院及报告、康复、死亡(SEINRHD)疫情传播模型。该模型基于中国COVID-19的流行病学特征构建,并考虑了社会接触网络的异质性。对武汉早期社区疫情爆发情况进行了重建,并与实际数据进行拟合。我们使用该模型从三个维度评估针对无症状感染者的疫情防控措施。基于有效再生数、异常高传播事件以及传播类型和结构,研究了无症状感染者对疫情传播的影响。对无症状感染者的管理有助于平缓感染曲线。追踪75%的无症状感染者对应的新增病例总体减少32.5%(与不追踪无症状感染者相比)。无论采取何种全人群措施,家庭传播高于其他类型的传播,估计占所有病例的50%。追踪无症状感染者的规模比时机更重要;当所有有症状患者都能及时被追踪、检测和隔离时,总体疫情对实施追踪无症状感染者措施的时间并不敏感。疫情期间应强调家庭内部的疾病防控。本文满足了评估无症状感染者引发另一场COVID-19疫情风险以及找到无症状感染者管理的最优、最实用方法的迫切需求。此前的研究大多聚焦于无症状感染者的临床和统计特征;很少有研究在社区层面使用数学模型评估针对无症状感染者措施的影响。本研究根据中国社区COVID-19的发展特征和趋势,基于当地社区结构和社会接触网络提出了一种易感、暴露、感染、无症状、住院及报告、康复、死亡(SEINRHD)传播模型。研究结论为疫情不同时期相关部门的应急工作提供了理论支持。在疫情早期,应优先及时发现和隔离有症状患者。在有额外防疫资源的情况下,有关部门应考虑提高追踪无症状感染者的比例。家庭成员间的防疫措施应是重点关注对象。这些策略相结合有助于降低病毒传播速度并最终扑灭疫情。