Kemal Özgür, Tahir Emel, Kavaz Esra, Karabulut Hüseyin
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Ondokuz Mayıs University School of Medicine, Samsun, Turkey.
Turk Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2022 Mar;60(1):36-41. doi: 10.4274/tao.2022.2021-12-10. Epub 2022 May 12.
This study aimed to differentiate the functional or aesthetic factors affecting the result of septorhinoplasty and to determine the most important factor related to patient satisfaction.
Rhinoplasty Outcome Evaluation (ROE) and Visual Analog Scale (VAS) for obstruction (VAS-O) and for appearance (VAS-A) were administered to fifty-five patients undergoing septorhinoplasty preoperatively and six months after the surgery. VAS scores were evaluated as follows: VAS-O (0: unblocked, 10: completely blocked) and VAS-A (0: worst appearance, 10: best appearance). ROE scores were calculated between 0 and 100. In order to examine the relationship between the measurements and determine the most powerful item that affects the overall ROE score, path analysis was performed, and the path coefficients were calculated.
The mean VAS-O and VAS-A scores before and after surgery were 6.85 and 4.36, and 3.91 and 7.22, respectively (p<0.001). The absolute value of mean difference was greater for VAS-A (-3.31) than VAS-O (-2.49), which also means appearance scores were more widely affected. The mean ROE score was increased from 46.36±9.28 to 78.85±11.70. VAS-A score had a significant impact on the overall ROE score (β=0.782, p=0.001), while the VAS-O score had no impact. The least effective item on the overall ROE score was item 2 (β=0.445), while the other items related to aesthetic outcome had higher Path coefficients.
Although septorhinoplasty provides satisfactory results in both functional and aesthetic aspects, patients are more satisfied with the cosmetic outcomes.
本研究旨在区分影响鼻中隔成形术效果的功能或美学因素,并确定与患者满意度相关的最重要因素。
对55例接受鼻中隔成形术的患者在术前及术后6个月进行鼻整形术结果评估(ROE)以及阻塞视觉模拟量表(VAS - O)和外观视觉模拟量表(VAS - A)。VAS评分评估如下:VAS - O(0:通畅,10:完全阻塞)和VAS - A(0:最差外观,10:最佳外观)。ROE评分在0至100之间计算。为了检验测量值之间的关系并确定影响总体ROE评分的最有力因素,进行了路径分析并计算了路径系数。
手术前后VAS - O和VAS - A的平均得分分别为6.85和4.36,以及3.91和7.22(p<0.001)。VAS - A的平均差异绝对值(-3.31)大于VAS - O(-2.49),这也意味着外观得分受到的影响更大。ROE平均得分从46.36±9.28提高到78.85±ll.70。VAS - A得分对总体ROE评分有显著影响(β = 0.782,p = 0.001),而VAS - O得分无影响。对总体ROE评分最无效的项目是项目2(β = 0.445),而其他与美学结果相关的项目具有更高的路径系数。
尽管鼻中隔成形术在功能和美学方面均提供了满意的结果,但患者对美容效果更满意。