Division of Research, Kaiser Permanente Northern California, Oakland, California, USA.
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Weill Institute for Neurosciences, University of California, San Francisco, California, USA.
Birth Defects Res. 2022 Aug 1;114(13):689-713. doi: 10.1002/bdr2.2060. Epub 2022 Jun 16.
Given increases in cannabis use in pregnancy and animal model research showing effects of in-utero cannabis exposure, high-quality information on long-term consequences of in-utero cannabis exposure in humans is needed. While reviews have summarized findings from observational studies with humans, reviews have not focused on limitations of these studies and recommendations for future research. Therefore, we critically reviewed observational research on in-utero cannabis exposure and psychiatric and neurodevelopmental outcomes measured at or after age 3 and provided recommendations for future research. We used Web of Science, Google Scholar, and work cited from relevant identified publications to identify 46 papers to include in our review. Our review includes two main sections. The first section highlights the extensive limitations of the existing research, which include small and nongeneralizable samples, reliance on self-reported data, lack of detail on timing and amount of exposure, inclusion of older exposure data only, not accounting for important confounders, inclusion of potential mediators as covariates, not including outcome severity measures, and not assessing for offspring sex differences. The second section provides recommendations for future research regarding exposure and outcome measures, sample selection, confounder adjustment, and other methodological considerations. For example, with regard to exposure definition, we recommend that studies quantify the amount of cannabis exposure, evaluate the influence of timing of exposure, and incorporate biological measures (e.g., urine toxicology measures). Given that high-quality information on long-term consequences of in-utero cannabis exposure in humans does not yet exit, it is crucial for future research to address the limitations we have identified.
鉴于怀孕期间大麻使用的增加,以及动物模型研究表明子宫内接触大麻会产生影响,因此需要高质量的信息来了解子宫内接触大麻对人类的长期后果。虽然综述已经总结了人类观察性研究的发现,但这些综述并未关注这些研究的局限性,以及对未来研究的建议。因此,我们批判性地审查了关于子宫内接触大麻与 3 岁及以上的精神和神经发育结果的观察性研究,并为未来的研究提供了建议。我们使用 Web of Science、Google Scholar 和相关已确定出版物的参考文献来确定了 46 篇论文纳入我们的综述。我们的综述包括两个主要部分。第一部分强调了现有研究的广泛局限性,包括样本量小且不可推广、依赖自我报告数据、缺乏关于暴露时间和数量的详细信息、仅纳入较旧的暴露数据、不考虑重要的混杂因素、将潜在的中介因素作为协变量纳入、不包括结果严重程度的衡量标准,以及不评估后代的性别差异。第二部分针对暴露和结果测量、样本选择、混杂因素调整以及其他方法学考虑因素提供了未来研究的建议。例如,就暴露定义而言,我们建议研究量化大麻暴露的数量,评估暴露时间的影响,并纳入生物测量(例如,尿液毒理学测量)。鉴于人类子宫内接触大麻的长期后果的高质量信息尚未存在,未来的研究必须解决我们所确定的局限性。