Centro Nacional de Microbiologia, Instituto de Salud Carlos III, Majadahonda, Madrid, Spain.
European Public Health Microbiology Training Programme (EUPHEM), European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC), Stockholm, Sweden.
Microbiol Spectr. 2022 Aug 31;10(4):e0104822. doi: 10.1128/spectrum.01048-22. Epub 2022 Jul 14.
On 30 September 2021, the city council of Muxia, Spain (population of 4,564 inhabitants), reported an unusual increase of patients with acute gastroenteritis (AGE). Because geographically widespread villages belonging to the same water supply were affected, a waterborne outbreak was suspected. Overall, 115 probable cases were ascertained during epidemiological investigations carried out by the local health authority (attack rate, 5.7%); the age range was 0 to 92 years, and 54% were female. The main symptoms were vomiting (78.1%) and diarrhea (67.5%). Primary cases peaked on 29 September and subsided on 1 October, compatible with a point-source outbreak followed by possible secondary cases until 7 October. We conducted an unmatched case-control study using phone surveys. The case-control study included 62 cases and 46 controls. Univariate analysis showed that cases had a higher exposure to tap water through direct consumption (odds ratio [OR] = 86; 95% confidence interval [CI], 18 to 409) or vegetable washing (OR = 27; 95% CI, 7 to 98). Norovirus GII was detected in two terminal points of the water supply system, and 14 cases were laboratory confirmed after detection of GII in stool samples. A unique genotype (GII.3[P12]) was identified in stool samples. On 1 October, a tap water ban was put in place and the water was purged and chlorinated. The rapid increase in the number of cases and its decline after implementing control measures suggested a waterborne point-source outbreak among the residents of Muxia sharing the same water distribution system. Noroviruses are likely to be underrecognized in most suspected waterborne outbreaks. Therefore, effective norovirus detection and the early recognition of water as a possible source of infection are important to reduce morbidity as appropriate steps are taken to control the source. In our study, we combined epidemiological, environmental, and microbiological investigations to demonstrate that it was a waterborne outbreak caused by norovirus. Metagenomic sequencing in one norovirus-positive stool sample confirmed norovirus etiology and the absence of other potential pathogens. Detection of fecal indicator bacteria and the fact that the drinking water was not chlorinated suggest a breakdown in chlorination as the cause of the outbreak. This outbreak investigation also demonstrated the importance of timely communication to the public about the risk linked to tap water consumption.
2021 年 9 月 30 日,西班牙穆夏市(人口 4564 人)市议会报告了一起不寻常的急性肠胃炎(AGE)病例增多事件。由于属于同一供水系统的地理分布广泛的村庄受到影响,因此怀疑是水源性暴发。在当地卫生部门进行的流行病学调查中,共确定了 115 例疑似病例(发病率为 5.7%);年龄范围为 0 至 92 岁,女性占 54%。主要症状为呕吐(78.1%)和腹泻(67.5%)。首例病例于 9 月 29 日达到高峰,并于 10 月 1 日消退,符合点源暴发后可能出现继发病例的情况,直至 10 月 7 日。我们使用电话调查进行了一项非匹配病例对照研究。病例对照研究包括 62 例病例和 46 例对照。单因素分析表明,病例组有更高的通过直接饮用(比值比[OR] = 86;95%置信区间[CI],18 至 409)或蔬菜清洗(OR = 27;95%CI,7 至 98)接触自来水的暴露风险。在供水系统的两个终端点检测到诺如病毒 GII,在粪便样本中检测到 GII 后,14 例病例得到实验室确认。在粪便样本中鉴定出一种独特的基因型(GII.3[P12])。10 月 1 日,实施了自来水禁令,并对水进行了冲洗和氯化。实施控制措施后,病例数迅速增加并下降,这表明 Muxia 的居民共享同一供水系统发生了水源性点源暴发。诺如病毒很可能在大多数疑似水源性暴发中未被识别。因此,有效检测诺如病毒并及早认识到水可能是感染源,对于减少发病率非常重要,并且应采取适当措施控制源头。在我们的研究中,我们结合了流行病学、环境和微生物学调查,证明这是一起由诺如病毒引起的水源性暴发。对一份诺如病毒阳性粪便样本进行的宏基因组测序证实了诺如病毒的病因,并排除了其他潜在病原体。粪便指示菌的检测以及饮用水未氯化的事实表明,氯化作用的失效是暴发的原因。此次暴发调查还证明了及时向公众通报与自来水消费相关的风险的重要性。