Lin Fen, Chen Xi, Cheng Edmund W
Department of Media and Communication, City University of Hong Kong, China.
Center for Public Affairs and Law, City University of Hong Kong, China.
Inf Process Manag. 2022 Sep;59(5):103013. doi: 10.1016/j.ipm.2022.103013. Epub 2022 Jul 16.
This study examines how perceived information overload and misinformation affect vaccine hesitancy and how this is moderated by structural and cultural factors. By applying and extending the fundamental cause theory, this study proposes a contextualized impact model to analyze a cross-national survey of 6034 residents in six societies in Asia, Europe and North America in June 2021. The study finds that (1) Older and highly-educated participants were less susceptible to COVID-19 information overload and belief in vaccine misinformation. (2) Perceived information overload led to an increase in vaccine acceptance and uptake, whereas belief in vaccine misinformation caused a decrease. (3) The structural differentiation of vaccine hesitancy was salient and higher socioeconomic status could buffer the negative impact of misinformation on vaccine acceptance. (4) Cultural factors such as collectivism and authoritarian mentality also served as buffers against the misinformation that reduced vaccine acceptance and uptake. These findings add nuanced footnotes to the fundamental causes theory and contribute to the discussion on the global recovery from the infodemic. Besides fact-checking and improving individual information literacy, effective and long-term information management and health policies must pay attention to stratified information gaps across socioeconomic groups, and to contextualize the communication and intervention strategies in different cultures.
本研究考察了感知到的信息过载和错误信息如何影响疫苗犹豫,以及结构和文化因素如何对其产生调节作用。通过应用和扩展根本原因理论,本研究提出了一个情境化影响模型,以分析2021年6月对亚洲、欧洲和北美的六个社会的6034名居民进行的一项跨国调查。研究发现:(1)年龄较大和受教育程度较高的参与者较不易受到新冠疫情信息过载的影响,也不太相信疫苗错误信息。(2)感知到的信息过载导致疫苗接受度和接种率上升,而相信疫苗错误信息则导致下降。(3)疫苗犹豫的结构差异显著,较高的社会经济地位可以缓冲错误信息对疫苗接受度的负面影响。(4)集体主义和威权心态等文化因素也可作为缓冲,抵御那些降低疫苗接受度和接种率的错误信息。这些发现为根本原因理论增添了细微差别,并有助于关于从信息疫情中实现全球复苏的讨论。除了进行事实核查和提高个人信息素养外,有效的长期信息管理和卫生政策必须关注社会经济群体之间分层的信息差距,并根据不同文化背景调整沟通和干预策略。