Yeung Andy Wai Kan
Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology, Applied Oral Sciences and Community Dental Care, Faculty of Dentistry, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China.
Healthcare (Basel). 2022 Jul 25;10(8):1382. doi: 10.3390/healthcare10081382.
The radiographic anatomy on dental panoramic images is essential knowledge for proper diagnosis and treatment planning purposes. No prior study has examined the content of YouTube videos with regard to radiographic anatomy on panoramic radiography. The objective of this study was to provide a content analysis on these videos. The initial search string was: (panoramic anatomy). An additional search was performed with the search string: (OPG landmarks). By screening the resultant videos and their related videos (recommended by YouTube as a list on the right of the screen), a total of 62 videos were screened. Videos were excluded if they were irrelevant (e.g., focusing on radiographic errors without covering the anatomy), elaborating mainly with drawings without showing the landmarks on panoramic images, duplicate videos, and non-English speaking. Finally, 38 videos were included and analyzed. Most of them showed clear panoramic images and had clear tracing or delineation of the anatomical landmarks. On average, each video described 26 landmarks, including 12.3 from the midfacial region, 8.2 from the mandible, and 5.2 from soft tissue/air space/others. The videos were of good quality in general, with some frequent shortcomings being lack of visual aid with skull and schematic diagrams, and lack of discussion on clinical relevance. The maxillary sinus was the structure mostly involved in wrong information, particularly the wrong delineation of its posterior wall.
牙科全景图像上的放射解剖学是正确诊断和治疗计划所必需的知识。此前尚无研究考察过YouTube上关于全景放射摄影放射解剖学的视频内容。本研究的目的是对这些视频进行内容分析。初始搜索词为:(全景解剖学)。还使用搜索词:(口腔全景X线片标志)进行了额外搜索。通过筛选所得视频及其相关视频(YouTube在屏幕右侧推荐列表中列出),共筛选了62个视频。如果视频不相关(例如,专注于放射摄影错误而未涵盖解剖结构)、主要用绘图阐述而未在全景图像上显示标志、重复视频以及非英语视频,则将其排除。最终纳入并分析了38个视频。其中大多数视频展示了清晰的全景图像,并且对解剖标志有清晰的描绘或勾勒。平均每个视频描述了26个标志,其中包括来自面中部区域的12.3个、来自下颌骨的8.2个以及来自软组织/气腔/其他部位的5.2个。总体而言,这些视频质量良好,但存在一些常见不足,即缺乏颅骨和示意图的视觉辅助,以及缺乏对临床相关性的讨论。上颌窦是错误信息涉及最多的结构,尤其是其后壁的错误描绘。