Center for the Study of Racism, Social Justice & Health, Fielding School of Public Health, UCLA, Los Angeles, CA.
Department of Health Policy and Management, Fielding School of Public Health, UCLA, Los Angeles, CA.
Ethn Dis. 2022 Jul 21;32(3):257-264. doi: 10.18865/ed.32.3.257. eCollection 2022 Summer.
The general public was discussing racism and potential inequities in COVID-19 vaccinations among African Americans on Twitter before the first COVID-19 vaccine received emergency use authorization, but it is unclear how US state health departments (SHDs) were using Twitter to address the inequities. This study examines the frequency, content and timing of SHD tweets during the US rollout of the first SARS Co-V2 vaccine.
This was a prospective study of tweets posted from the official Twitter accounts of each of the 50 US SHDs and the DC health department from October 19, 2020 to February 28, 2021. We retrieved the content and metadata of 100% of their tweets; calculated frequencies and proportions of tweets containing key terms related to COVID-19 vaccines, equity and racism; stratified the data by region; and charted longitudinal trends.
Overall, SHDs tweeted infrequently, and rarely tweeted about inequities, mistrust or racism. Though 55.48% of all SHD tweets were about COVID-19, hardly any tweets contained the terms: race/ethnicity (1.20%); equity (1.09); mistrust (.59%); or racism (.06%). Similar patterns existed among vaccination-related tweets, which accounted for 24.38% of all tweets. Only 21.64% of vaccination-related tweets containing any race/ethnicity, equity, mistrust, or racism terms were posted prior to the first Emergency Use Authorization (EUA). Those about African Americans (70.45%) were posted ≥8 weeks after EUA.
Concerns about racism and inequities in COVID-19 vaccination continue on Twitter, but SHDs rarely tweet about them. This strikes a worrisome chord of disconnection from the science linking health inequities to racism.
在第一批 COVID-19 疫苗获得紧急使用授权之前,公众就在 Twitter 上讨论了非裔美国人的种族主义和 COVID-19 疫苗接种方面的潜在不平等现象,但美国州卫生部门(SHD)如何利用 Twitter 来解决这些不平等问题尚不清楚。本研究考察了在美国推出第一批 SARS Co-V2 疫苗期间,SHD 在 Twitter 上发布的频率、内容和时间。
这是一项对 2020 年 10 月 19 日至 2021 年 2 月 28 日期间,美国 50 个州 SHD 和华盛顿特区卫生部门的官方 Twitter 账户发布的推文进行的前瞻性研究。我们检索了他们所有推文的内容和元数据;计算了与 COVID-19 疫苗、公平和种族主义相关的关键词的推文频率和比例;按区域划分数据;并绘制了纵向趋势图。
总体而言,SHD 很少在 Twitter 上发布推文,且很少发布有关不平等、不信任或种族主义的推文。尽管 55.48%的 SHD 推文都与 COVID-19 相关,但几乎没有推文包含以下术语:种族/族裔(1.20%);公平(1.09%);不信任(.59%);或种族主义(.06%)。在与疫苗接种相关的推文中也存在类似的模式,占所有推文的 24.38%。仅在获得第一批紧急使用授权(EUA)之前发布了包含任何种族/族裔、公平、不信任或种族主义术语的 21.64%的疫苗接种相关推文。其中关于非裔美国人的推文(70.45%)是在 EUA 之后 8 周以上发布的。
在 Twitter 上,人们对 COVID-19 疫苗接种中的种族主义和不平等现象的担忧仍在继续,但 SHD 很少发布相关推文。这与将健康不平等与种族主义联系起来的科学观点脱节,令人担忧。