Department of Cardiology, Kerckhoff-Klinik, Benekestr. 2-8, 61231, Bad Nauheim, Germany.
Practice for general medicine Dres.Ott&Schoening, Karlstr. 3, 63579, Freigericht, Germany.
Wien Med Wochenschr. 2024 Jun;174(9-10):181-188. doi: 10.1007/s10354-022-00951-0. Epub 2022 Aug 10.
Adult education centers are an important part of health education worldwide. Our aim was to evaluate the courses offered by German adult education centers with regard to complementary medicine and nutrition.
A systematic web-based search was done for the websites of German adult education centers and courses were analyzed considering topics, scientific soundness, and qualification of instructors.
Our search revealed 502 courses, 360 (71.7%) related to complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) and 176 courses on nutrition (35.1%). CAM courses most often presented methods with a focus on traditional Eastern medicine with yoga and similar mind-body practices (41.9%), traditional Chinese medicine (TCM; 13.3%), and ayurvedic medicine (11.4%). Content concerning nutrition mainly included controversial fasting methods like alkaline fasting, detox diets, and therapeutic fasting (43.8%), as well as Eastern traditional diets from TCM and ayurveda (21.7%). Most of the courses were given by non-medical practitioners (NMPs; 36.4%), while only very few physicians were engaged.
There are substantial doubts on the scientific background of many courses offered for lay adult health education. Besides direct misinformation, many courses reinforce alternative and non-evidence-based notions in society. Adult education centers should reconsider the topics of their courses as well as the professional qualifications of the instructors.
成人教育中心是全球健康教育的重要组成部分。我们的目的是评估德国成人教育中心提供的补充医学和营养课程。
我们对德国成人教育中心的网站进行了系统的网络搜索,并对课程进行了分析,考虑了主题、科学性和教师资质。
我们的搜索结果显示有 502 门课程,其中 360 门(71.7%)与补充和替代医学(CAM)有关,176 门与营养有关(35.1%)。CAM 课程最常介绍以传统东方医学为重点的方法,包括瑜伽和类似的身心实践(41.9%)、中医(TCM;13.3%)和顺势疗法(11.4%)。关于营养的内容主要包括有争议的禁食方法,如碱性禁食、排毒饮食和治疗性禁食(43.8%),以及来自 TCM 和顺势疗法的东方传统饮食(21.7%)。大多数课程由非医疗从业者(NMPs;36.4%)讲授,只有极少数医生参与。
许多为成人健康教育提供的课程在科学性方面存在很大疑问。除了直接的错误信息外,许多课程还强化了社会上的替代和非循证观念。成人教育中心应重新考虑其课程的主题以及教师的专业资质。