Rosenberg Nora E, Obiezu-Umeh Chisom, Gbaja-Biamila Titilola, Tahlil Kadija M, Nwaozuru Ucheoma, Oladele David, Musa Adesola Z, Idigbe Ifeoma, Okwuzu Jane, David Agatha N, Bamidele Tajudeen A, Tang Weiming, Ezechi Oliver, Tucker Joseph D, Iwelunmor Juliet
Department of Health Behavior, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, USA.
Department of Behavioral Science and Health Education, Saint Louis University, Saint Louis, MO, USA.
BMJ Innov. 2021 Jul;7(3):590-596. doi: 10.1136/bmjinnov-2020-000556. Epub 2018 Oct 21.
Youth are often the intended beneficiaries of HIV programs but are rarely involved in program design. Engaging youth in program design is one potential way of identifying promising approaches for HIV service delivery. The purpose of this study is to examine the feasibility of using a crowdsourcing contest to solicit ideas on ways to promote HIV self-testing (HIVST) services among Nigerian youths.
From October-November, 2018 Nigerian youth 10-24 years old submitted ideas to a crowdsourcing contest on how to promote HIVST among their peers. Submissions were scored on feasibility, desirability, and impact, with an integer score of 1 (low) to 3 (high) in each domain. The three-domain scores were added to calculate a total score (3-9). The demographic characteristics of contestants were calculated using descriptive statistics.
Nine-hundred and three entries were received, 831 had unique valid responses, and 769 were eligible for scoring. Youth submitted ideas on paper (44.9%), Google Forms (39.4%), WhatsApp (9.6%), and email (6.1%). Participants' ages were 10-14 years (37%), 15-19 years (44%), and 20-24 years (22%).Approximately half were female (51.2%). Mean scores were 1.4/3.0 (SD=0.6) for feasibility, 1.4/3.0 (SD=0.6) for desirability, 1.2/3.0 (SD=0.5) for impact, and 4.0/9.0 (SD=1.5) overall. Eight percent of submissions had an overall score >7. A disproportionate share of these high-quality submissions came from email and Google submissions.
The 4 Youth by Youth crowdsourcing contest engaged a broad audience and is a feasible way to elicit potential strategies to distribute HIVST kits to other youth. Several high-quality ideas require further evaluation.
青少年往往是艾滋病项目的预期受益者,但他们很少参与项目设计。让青少年参与项目设计是确定有前景的艾滋病服务提供方式的一种潜在途径。本研究的目的是检验利用众包竞赛征集在尼日利亚青少年中推广艾滋病自我检测(HIVST)服务方法的可行性。
2018年10月至11月,10至24岁的尼日利亚青少年就如何在同龄人中推广HIVST向一场众包竞赛提交了想法。提交内容根据可行性、可取性和影响力进行评分,每个领域的整数评分从1(低)到3(高)。将这三个领域的分数相加计算出总分(3至9分)。使用描述性统计计算参赛者的人口统计学特征。
共收到903份参赛作品,831份有独特的有效回复,769份符合评分条件。青少年通过纸质形式(44.9%)、谷歌表单(39.4%)、WhatsApp(9.6%)和电子邮件(6.1%)提交想法。参与者年龄为10至14岁(37%)、15至19岁(44%)和20至24岁(22%)。约一半为女性(51.2%)。可行性平均得分为1.4/3.0(标准差=0.6),可取性平均得分为1.4/3.0(标准差=0.6),影响力平均得分为1.2/3.0(标准差=0.5),总体平均得分为4.0/9.0(标准差=1.5)。8%的提交作品总分>7分。这些高质量提交作品中不成比例的一部分来自电子邮件和谷歌提交方式。
“青少年助力青少年”众包竞赛吸引了广泛的受众,是引出向其他青少年分发HIVST检测包潜在策略的一种可行方式。一些高质量想法需要进一步评估。