Hansen Heather A, Stefancin Patricia, Leber Andrew B, Saygin Zeynep M
Department of Psychology, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, United States.
Front Neurosci. 2022 Aug 9;16:880759. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2022.880759. eCollection 2022.
Misophonia, an extreme aversion to certain environmental sounds, is a highly prevalent yet understudied condition plaguing roughly 20% of the general population. Although neuroimaging research on misophonia is scant, recent work showing higher resting-state functional connectivity (rs-fMRI) between auditory cortex and orofacial motor cortex in misophonia vs. controls has led researchers to speculate that misophonia is caused by orofacial mirror neurons. Since orofacial motor cortex was defined using rs-fMRI, we attempted to theoretically replicate these findings using orofacial cortex defined by task-based fMRI instead. Further, given our recent work showing that a wide variety of sounds can be triggering (i.e., not just oral/nasal sounds), we investigated whether there is any neural evidence for misophonic aversion to non-orofacial stimuli. Sampling 19 adults with varying misophonia from the community, we collected resting state data and an fMRI task involving phoneme articulation and finger-tapping. We first defined "orofacial" cortex in each participant using rs-fMRI as done previously, producing what we call resting-state regions of interest (rsROIs). Additionally, we functionally defined regions (fROIs) representing "orofacial" or "finger" cortex using phoneme or finger-tapping activation from the fMRI task, respectively. To investigate the motor specificity of connectivity differences, we subdivided the rsROIs and fROIs into separate sensorimotor areas based on their overlap with two common atlases. We then calculated rs-fMRI between each rsROI/fROI and non-sensorimotor ROIs. We found increased connectivity in mild misophonia between rsROIs and both auditory cortex and insula, theoretically replicating previous results, with differences extending across multiple sensorimotor regions. However, the orofacial task-based fROIs did not show this pattern, suggesting the "orofacial" cortex described previously was not capturing true orofacial cortex; in fact, using task-based fMRI evidence, we find no selectivity to orofacial action in these previously described "orofacial" regions. Instead, we observed higher connectivity between finger fROIs and insula in mild misophonia, demonstrating neural evidence for non-orofacial triggers. These results provide support for a neural representation of misophonia beyond merely an orofacial/motor origin, leading to important implications for the conceptualization and treatment of misophonia.
恐音症是对某些环境声音的极度厌恶,是一种高度普遍但研究不足的病症,困扰着约20%的普通人群。尽管关于恐音症的神经影像学研究很少,但最近的研究表明,与对照组相比,恐音症患者听觉皮层和口面部运动皮层之间的静息态功能连接(rs-fMRI)更高,这使得研究人员推测恐音症是由口面部镜像神经元引起的。由于口面部运动皮层是使用rs-fMRI定义的,我们试图从理论上使用基于任务的fMRI定义的口面部皮层来复制这些发现。此外,鉴于我们最近的研究表明各种各样的声音都可能引发(即不仅仅是口腔/鼻腔声音),我们研究了是否有任何神经证据表明恐音症患者对非口面部刺激存在厌恶。我们从社区中抽取了19名患有不同程度恐音症的成年人,收集了静息态数据以及一项涉及音素发音和手指敲击的fMRI任务数据。我们首先像之前那样使用rs-fMRI在每个参与者中定义“口面部”皮层,生成我们所谓的静息态感兴趣区域(rsROIs)。此外,我们分别使用fMRI任务中的音素或手指敲击激活来功能定义代表“口面部”或“手指”皮层的区域(fROIs)。为了研究连接差异的运动特异性,我们根据rsROIs和fROIs与两个常用图谱的重叠情况,将它们细分为单独的感觉运动区域。然后我们计算每个rsROI/fROI与非感觉运动ROIs之间的rs-fMRI。我们发现轻度恐音症患者的rsROIs与听觉皮层和脑岛之间的连接性增加,从理论上复制了先前的结果,差异延伸到多个感觉运动区域。然而,基于口面部任务的fROIs并没有显示出这种模式,这表明先前描述的“口面部”皮层并没有捕捉到真正的口面部皮层;事实上,根据基于任务的fMRI证据,我们发现在这些先前描述的“口面部”区域中对口面部动作没有选择性。相反,我们观察到轻度恐音症患者手指fROIs与脑岛之间的连接性更高,这证明了非口面部触发因素的神经证据。这些结果为恐音症的神经表征提供了支持,表明其不仅仅源于口面部/运动,这对恐音症的概念化和治疗具有重要意义。