Gao Yunyuan, Liu Hongming, Fang Feng, Zhang Yingchun
IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 2023 Mar;70(3):877-887. doi: 10.1109/TBME.2022.3204718. Epub 2023 Feb 17.
Human brain breaks the detailed balance to drive a variety of cognitive functions, such as memory. Recently, a promising classification framework of working memory loads has been proposed based on functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data with relative entropy (RE) measurement to quantify the broken detailed balance of human brain. However, there are limitations in previousely developed methods. First, single-modality fMRI can only detect the cerebral hemodynamics but not the neuronal activity, lacking detailed information of the neurovascular coupling process in the brain. Second, the RE measurement utilized to quantify the broken detailed balance may be biased and have no finite upper bound, limiting its application in high dimensional signal domains. In this study, a neurovascular coupling strategy based on concurrent electroencephalography (EEG) and functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS) recordings was proposed to take both the cerebral hemedynamics and neuronal activity into consideration in assessing broken detailed balance of the brain. Furthermore, the generalized relative entropy (GRE) was employed to reduce the bias associated with the conventional RE measure. Our results demonstrated that the proposed framework showed higher classification accuracy (82.48%) to identify different levels of working memory loads than conventional methods. In addition, our results revealed that the broken detailed balance was significantly stronger when subjects performed cognitively demanding tasks (P<0.05) and was highly correlated with the neurovascular coupling models derived from the EEG θ and α bands, respectively. In conclusion, our findings provide an advanced framework to accurately classify various levels of working memory with the broken detailed balance of human brain and can be extended to explore the underlying broken detailed balance related to other cognitive behaviors and diseases.
人类大脑打破精细平衡以驱动多种认知功能,如记忆。最近,基于功能磁共振成像(fMRI)数据并采用相对熵(RE)测量来量化人类大脑打破的精细平衡,提出了一个很有前景的工作记忆负荷分类框架。然而,先前开发的方法存在局限性。首先,单模态fMRI只能检测脑血流动力学,而不能检测神经元活动,缺乏大脑中神经血管耦合过程的详细信息。其次,用于量化打破的精细平衡的RE测量可能存在偏差且没有有限的上限,限制了其在高维信号域中的应用。在本研究中,提出了一种基于同步脑电图(EEG)和功能近红外光谱(fNIRS)记录的神经血管耦合策略,在评估大脑打破的精细平衡时同时考虑脑血流动力学和神经元活动。此外,采用广义相对熵(GRE)来减少与传统RE测量相关的偏差。我们的结果表明,与传统方法相比,所提出的框架在识别不同水平的工作记忆负荷方面具有更高的分类准确率(82.48%)。此外,我们的结果显示,当受试者执行认知要求较高的任务时,打破的精细平衡明显更强(P<0.05),并且分别与从EEG θ和α波段导出的神经血管耦合模型高度相关。总之,我们的研究结果提供了一个先进的框架,以利用人类大脑打破的精细平衡准确分类各种水平的工作记忆,并且可以扩展到探索与其他认知行为和疾病相关的潜在打破的精细平衡。