The Biorobotics Institute, Scuola Superiore Sant'Anna, Viale Rinaldo Piaggio 34, 56025, Pontedera, Italy.
IRCCS Fondazione Don Carlo Gnocchi Onlus, Via di Scandicci 269, 50143, Florence, Italy.
J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2022 Sep 7;19(1):96. doi: 10.1186/s12984-022-01075-7.
Rehabilitation treatments and services are essential for the recovery of post-stroke patients' functions; however, the increasing number of available therapies and the lack of consensus among outcome measures compromises the possibility to determine an appropriate level of evidence. Machine learning techniques for prognostic applications offer accurate and interpretable predictions, supporting the clinical decision for personalised treatment. The aim of this study is to develop and cross-validate predictive models for the functional prognosis of patients, highlighting the contributions of each predictor.
A dataset of 278 post-stroke patients was used for the prediction of the class transition, obtained from the modified Barthel Index. Four classification algorithms were cross-validated and compared. On the best performing model on the validation set, an analysis of predictors contribution was conducted.
The Random Forest obtained the best overall results on the accuracy (76.2%), balanced accuracy (74.3%), sensitivity (0.80), and specificity (0.68). The combination of all the classification results on the test set, by weighted voting, reached 80.2% accuracy. The predictors analysis applied on the Support Vector Machine, showed that a good trunk control and communication level, and the absence of bedsores retain the major contribution in the prediction of a good functional outcome.
Despite a more comprehensive assessment of the patients is needed, this work paves the way for the implementation of solutions for clinical decision support in the rehabilitation of post-stroke patients. Indeed, offering good prognostic accuracies for class transition and patient-wise view of the predictors contributions, it might help in a personalised optimisation of the patients' rehabilitation path.
康复治疗和服务对于脑卒中患者功能恢复至关重要;然而,可供选择的治疗方法越来越多,且缺乏共识的结果衡量标准,这使得确定适当的证据水平变得困难。用于预后应用的机器学习技术提供了准确且可解释的预测结果,为个性化治疗的临床决策提供支持。本研究旨在开发和交叉验证患者功能预后的预测模型,突出每个预测指标的贡献。
使用从改良巴氏指数获得的 278 名脑卒中患者数据集来预测类别转换。对四种分类算法进行交叉验证和比较。在验证集上表现最佳的模型上,进行了预测指标贡献分析。
随机森林在准确性(76.2%)、平衡准确性(74.3%)、敏感性(0.80)和特异性(0.68)方面获得了最佳的总体结果。通过加权投票,将测试集上所有分类结果组合,达到 80.2%的准确性。在支持向量机上应用的预测指标分析表明,良好的躯干控制和沟通能力以及没有褥疮保留了对良好功能预后预测的主要贡献。
尽管需要对患者进行更全面的评估,但这项工作为在脑卒中患者康复中实施临床决策支持解决方案铺平了道路。实际上,它提供了对类别转换的良好预后准确性和对患者预测指标贡献的个体视角,有助于患者康复路径的个性化优化。