Department of Orthodontics, School of Dentistry, LSU Health New Orleans, 1100, Florida Avenue, 70119 New Orleans, LA, USA.
Department of Biostatistics, School of Public Health, LSU Health New Orleans, 2020, Gravier Street, 70112 New Orleans, LA, USA.
Int Orthod. 2022 Dec;20(4):100691. doi: 10.1016/j.ortho.2022.100691. Epub 2022 Sep 14.
To compare the reliability of cephalometric landmark identification by an automated tracing software based on convolutional neural networks to human tracers.
Sixty cephalograms were traced by two board-certified orthodontists and AudaxCeph®'s artificial intelligence software. The following thirteen landmarks were identified in each tracing: Sella, Nasion, A point, B point, Porion, Menton, Pogonion, Orbitale, Gonion, Upper Central Incisor Incisal Edge (U1 Tip), Upper Central Incisor Root Apex (U1 apex), Lower Central Incisor Incisal Edge (L1 Tip), Lower Central Incisor Root Apex (L1 apex). An x-y axis was positioned in the bottom left corner of each cephalogram, and the x- and y-coordinates for the landmarks were exported into Excel. Distributions of landmarks (X, Y, radial distance) were compared using t-tests of equivalence with a 2mm equivalence bound. These compared the AI position to the two orthodontists - and the orthodontists' reliability by comparing equivalence against each other.
There was no statistical difference between the orthodontists and AudaxCeph®'s automatic tracing software except for the x- and y-dimension of Porion and the y-dimension of L1 apex. The two orthodontists had good intra-examiner reliability with no statistical difference found when comparing them.
AudaxCeph®'s automated cephalometric tracing software is a good adjunctive tool to use when diagnosing and treatment planning orthodontic cases.
比较基于卷积神经网络的自动追踪软件与人工追踪在头影测量标志点识别方面的可靠性。
由两名认证的正畸医生和 AudaxCeph®的人工智能软件对 60 张头颅侧位片进行追踪。在每张追踪片上都识别了以下 13 个标志点:蝶鞍(Sella)、鼻根点(Nasion)、A 点、B 点、眶点(Porion)、颏顶点(Menton)、颏前点(Pogonion)、眶下点(Orbitale)、关节点(Gonion)、上中切牙切缘(U1 Tip)、上中切牙根尖(U1 apex)、下中切牙切缘(L1 Tip)、下中切牙根尖(L1 apex)。在每张头颅侧位片的左下角放置一个 x-y 轴,将标志点的 x-和 y-坐标导出到 Excel 中。使用等效性 t 检验比较标志点的分布(X、Y、放射距离),等效边界为 2mm。将 AI 位置与两位正畸医生进行比较,并将两位正畸医生的可靠性进行比较,即彼此之间的等效性比较。
除了眶点的 x-和 y-维度以及下中切牙根尖的 y-维度外,正畸医生和 AudaxCeph®的自动追踪软件之间没有统计学差异。两位正畸医生的内部检查者可靠性良好,彼此之间没有统计学差异。
AudaxCeph®的自动头影测量追踪软件是诊断和治疗计划正畸病例的良好辅助工具。