Meszaros Janos, Minari Jusaku, Huys Isabelle
Division of Clinical Pharmacology and Pharmacotherapy, Department of Pharmaceutical and Pharmacological Sciences, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
Centre for IT and IP Law (CiTiP), KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
Front Genet. 2022 Oct 4;13:927721. doi: 10.3389/fgene.2022.927721. eCollection 2022.
Despite its promising future, the application of artificial intelligence (AI) and automated decision-making in healthcare services and medical research faces several legal and ethical hurdles. The European Union (EU) is tackling these issues with the existing legal framework and drafting new regulations, such as the proposed AI Act. The EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) partly regulates AI systems, with rules on processing personal data and protecting data subjects against solely automated decision-making. In healthcare services, (automated) decisions are made more frequently and rapidly. However, medical research focuses on innovation and efficacy, with less direct decisions on individuals. Therefore, the GDPR's restrictions on solely automated decision-making apply mainly to healthcare services, and the rights of patients and research participants may significantly differ. The proposed AI Act introduced a risk-based approach to AI systems based on the principles of ethical AI. We analysed the complex connection between the GDPR and AI Act, highlighting the main issues and finding ways to harmonise the principles of data protection and ethical AI. The proposed AI Act may complement the GDPR in healthcare services and medical research. Although several years may pass before the AI Act comes into force, many of its goals will be realised before that.
尽管人工智能(AI)和自动化决策在医疗服务和医学研究领域有着光明的前景,但其应用仍面临一些法律和伦理障碍。欧盟(EU)正在利用现有法律框架应对这些问题,并起草新的法规,如拟议的《人工智能法案》。欧盟的《通用数据保护条例》(GDPR)部分规范了人工智能系统,对处理个人数据以及保护数据主体免受仅基于自动化的决策影响制定了规则。在医疗服务中,(自动化)决策的做出更为频繁和迅速。然而,医学研究侧重于创新和疗效,对个体的直接决策较少。因此,GDPR对仅基于自动化的决策的限制主要适用于医疗服务,患者和研究参与者的权利可能存在显著差异。拟议的《人工智能法案》基于合乎伦理的人工智能原则,引入了一种针对人工智能系统的基于风险的方法。我们分析了GDPR与《人工智能法案》之间的复杂联系,突出了主要问题,并找到了协调数据保护原则与合乎伦理的人工智能原则的方法。拟议的《人工智能法案》可能会在医疗服务和医学研究中补充GDPR。尽管《人工智能法案》可能需要数年时间才能生效,但其许多目标在此之前就会实现。