Steve Hicks School of Social Work, University of Texas at Austin.
Texas Policy Evaluation Project, Austin.
JAMA. 2022 Nov 22;328(20):2048-2055. doi: 10.1001/jama.2022.20423.
Texas' 2021 ban on abortion in early pregnancy may demonstrate how patterns of abortion might change following the US Supreme Court's June 2022 decision overturning Roe v Wade.
To assess changes in the number of abortions and changes in the percentage of out-of-state abortions among Texas residents performed at 12 or more weeks of gestation in the first 6 months following implementation of Texas Senate Bill 8 (SB 8), which prohibited abortions after detection of embryonic cardiac activity.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Retrospective study of a sample of 50 Texas and out-of-state abortion facilities using an interrupted time series analysis to assess changes in the number of abortions, and Poisson regression to assess changes in abortions at 12 or more weeks of gestation. Data included 68 820 Texas facility-based abortions and 11 287 out-of-state abortions among Texas residents during the study period from September 1, 2020, to February 28, 2022.
Abortion care obtained after (September 2021-February 2022) vs before (September 2020-August 2021) implementation of SB 8.
Primary outcomes were changes in the number of facility-based abortions for Texas residents, in Texas and out of state, in the month after implementation of SB 8 compared with the month before. The secondary outcome was the change in the percentage of out-of-state abortions among Texas residents obtained at 12 or more weeks of gestation during the 6-month period after the law's implementation.
Between September 2020 and August 2021, there were 55 018 abortions in Texas and 2547 out-of-state abortions among Texas residents. During the 6 months after SB 8, there were 13 802 abortions in Texas and 8740 out-of-state abortions among Texas residents. Compared with the month before implementation of SB 8, the number of Texas facility-based abortions significantly decreased from 5451 to 2169 (difference, -3282 [95% CI, -3171 to -3396]; incidence rate ratio [IRR], 0.43 [95% CI, 0.36-0.51]) in the month after SB 8 was implemented. The number of out-of-state abortions among Texas residents significantly increased from 222 to 1332 (difference, 1110 [95% CI, 1047-1177]; IRR, 5.38 [95% CI, 4.19-6.91]). Overall, the total documented number of Texas facility-based and out-of-state abortions among Texas residents significantly decreased from 5673 to 3501 (absolute change, -2172 [95% CI, -2083 to -2265]; IRR, 0.67 [95% CI, 0.56-0.79]) in the first month after SB 8 was implemented compared with the previous month. Out-of-state abortions among Texas residents obtained at 12 or more weeks of gestation increased from 17.1% (221/1291) to 31.0% (399/1289) (difference, 178 [95% CI, 153-206]) during the period between September 2021 and February 2022 (P < .001 for trend).
Among a sample of abortion facilities, the 2021 Texas law banning abortion in early pregnancy (SB 8) was significantly associated with a decrease in the documented total of facility-based abortions in Texas and obtained by Texas residents in surrounding states in the first month after implementation compared with the previous month. Over the 6 months following SB 8 implementation, the percentage of out-of-state abortions among Texas residents obtained at 12 or more weeks of gestation significantly increased.
德克萨斯州 2021 年禁止早期妊娠堕胎的规定可能表明,在美国最高法院 2022 年 6 月推翻罗诉韦德案后,堕胎模式可能会发生变化。
评估在德克萨斯州参议院法案 8 (SB 8)实施后的第 12 周或以上进行的德克萨斯州居民堕胎数量的变化,以及在该法案禁止胚胎心脏活动检测后进行的堕胎数量的百分比变化。
设计、地点和参与者:利用中断时间序列分析评估堕胎数量变化的回顾性研究,使用泊松回归评估 12 周或以上妊娠的堕胎变化。数据包括 2020 年 9 月 1 日至 2022 年 2 月 28 日期间研究期间来自 50 家德克萨斯州和外州堕胎机构的 68400 名基于机构的堕胎和 11287 名德克萨斯州居民的外州堕胎。
在(2021 年 9 月至 2 月)实施 SB 8 后与之前(2020 年 9 月至 8 月)获得的堕胎护理。
主要结果是在 SB 8 实施后的一个月内,与实施前一个月相比,德克萨斯州居民在德克萨斯州和外州进行的基于机构的堕胎数量的变化。次要结果是在该法律实施后的 6 个月内,德克萨斯州居民在 12 周或以上妊娠时获得的外州堕胎百分比的变化。
在 2020 年 9 月至 2021 年 8 月期间,德克萨斯州有 55018 例堕胎和 2547 例外州堕胎。在 SB 8 实施后的 6 个月内,德克萨斯州有 13802 例堕胎和 8740 例外州堕胎。与实施 SB 8 前一个月相比,德克萨斯州基于机构的堕胎数量从 5451 例显著减少到 2169 例(差异,-3282[95%CI,-3171 至-3396];发病率比[IRR],0.43[95%CI,0.36-0.51])。德克萨斯州居民的外州堕胎数量从 222 例显著增加到 1332 例(差异,1110[95%CI,1047 至 1177];IRR,5.38[95%CI,4.19 至 6.91])。总体而言,德克萨斯州居民的基于机构的堕胎和外州堕胎的总记录数量从 5673 例显著减少到 3501 例(绝对变化,-2172[95%CI,-2083 至-2265];IRR,0.67[95%CI,0.56-0.79])在 SB 8 实施后的第一个月与前一个月相比。在 12 周或以上妊娠时获得的德克萨斯州居民的外州堕胎数量从 17.1%(221/1291)增加到 31.0%(399/1289)(差异,178[95%CI,153-206])(P < 0.001 趋势)。
在堕胎机构样本中,2021 年德克萨斯州禁止早期妊娠堕胎的法律(SB 8)与实施后的第一个月内德克萨斯州居民在该州和周边州进行的基于机构的堕胎数量以及实施后的第一个月内记录的堕胎数量显著减少相关。在 SB 8 实施后的 6 个月内,德克萨斯州居民在 12 周或以上妊娠时获得的外州堕胎的百分比显著增加。