Al-Nuwaiser Waleed M
Department of Computer Science, College of Computer and Information Sciences, Al-Imam Mohamed Ibn Saud Islamic University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
PeerJ Comput Sci. 2022 Nov 15;8:e1153. doi: 10.7717/peerj-cs.1153. eCollection 2022.
People receive a wide variety of news from social media. They especially look for information on social media in times of crisis with the desire to assess the risk they face. This risk assessment, and other aspects of user reactions, may be affected by characteristics of the social media post relaying certain information. Thus, it is critical to understand these characteristics to deliver information with the reactions in mind. This study investigated various types of imagery used as thumbnails in social media posts regarding news about the COVID-19 pandemic. In an experimental design, 300 participants viewed social media posts containing each of the three types of imagery: data visualization (directly about risk information), advisory (not containing direct risk information, but instead help on how to lower risk), or clickbait (containing no risk-related information, just generic visuals). After observing the social media posts, they answered questionnaires measuring their emotions (valence, arousal, and dominance), risk perception, perceived credibility of the post, and engagement. The participants also indicated their emotions towards and interest in COVID-19 news coverage, age, gender, and how often and actively they use social media. These variables acted as controls. The data were analysed using mixed linear models. Results indicated that advisory imagery positively influenced valence, arousal, dominance, credibility, and (lower) risk perception. Alternatively, imagery showing data visualizations yielded low valence, arousal, dominance, credibility, and high risk perception. Clickbait-styled thumbnails which carry no information are usually measured between the other two types. The type of imagery did not affect the motivation to engage with a post. Aside from visual imagery, most variables were affected by COVID sentiment and the usual activity on social media. These study results indicate that one should use advisory imagery for more comfortable news delivery and data visualization when the poster wishes to warn users of existing risks.
人们从社交媒体上获取各种各样的新闻。在危机时期,他们尤其会在社交媒体上寻找信息,以评估自己面临的风险。这种风险评估以及用户反应的其他方面,可能会受到传递某些信息的社交媒体帖子特征的影响。因此,了解这些特征对于在传递信息时考虑到用户反应至关重要。本研究调查了在社交媒体帖子中用作缩略图的各种类型的图像,这些帖子是关于新冠疫情的新闻。在一项实验设计中,300名参与者观看了包含三种类型图像的社交媒体帖子:数据可视化(直接关于风险信息)、咨询性(不包含直接风险信息,而是关于如何降低风险的帮助)或标题党(不包含与风险相关的信息,只有一般的视觉效果)。在观察完社交媒体帖子后,他们回答了测量其情绪(效价、唤醒度和支配性)、风险感知、帖子的可信度感知以及参与度的问卷。参与者还表明了他们对新冠新闻报道的情绪和兴趣、年龄、性别,以及他们使用社交媒体的频率和活跃度。这些变量作为控制因素。数据使用混合线性模型进行分析。结果表明,咨询性图像对效价、唤醒度、支配性、可信度以及(较低的)风险感知有积极影响。相反,显示数据可视化的图像产生了低效价、唤醒度、支配性、可信度和高风险感知。不携带信息的标题党式缩略图通常在其他两种类型之间。图像类型不会影响参与帖子的动机。除了视觉图像外,大多数变量受到新冠情绪和社交媒体上的日常活动的影响。这些研究结果表明,当发布者希望提醒用户注意现有风险时,应该使用咨询性图像进行更舒适的新闻传递,并使用数据可视化。