Gastroenterology and Digestive Oncology Department, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Reims, Hospital Robert Debré, Rue du Général Koenig, 51100, Reims, France.
Anatomy Department, Université de Reims Champagne Ardenne, Reims, France.
Surg Endosc. 2023 Apr;37(4):3224-3232. doi: 10.1007/s00464-022-09763-0. Epub 2022 Nov 28.
The reperfused human cadaver is a validated simulator for surgery. We aimed to use it as a colonoscopy simulator.
Novices, intermediates and skilled participants in gastrointestinal endoscopy were included. They performed one colonoscopy on a reperfused human cadaver and reaching rates, time, and length needed to reach anatomical landmarks were reported for construct validity analysis. We also assessed our model realism (SRS survey), educational content (CVS survey) and task load (NASA-TLX index). Score items were collected and defined as "favorable" when items were rated ≥ 5/7 with an inter-quartile range (IQR) overlapping four, and "very favorable" when rated ≥ 5/7 with an IQR excluding four (neutral). Primary endpoints were the rectosigmoid junction (RSJ) reaching rate and the descending colon (DC) reaching time. Secondary objectives were SRS, CVS and NASA-TLX questionnaire results.
A total of 11 skilled participants, 5 intermediates and 8 novices were included. Skilled participants reached RSJ more often than novice and intermediary groups, respectively, 100%, 80% and 75% without differing significantly. They reached DC more frequently (100% for skilled, 80% for intermediates and 50% for novices, p = 0.018). The median time to reach RSJ (59, 272 and 686 s for skilled, intermediates and novices group, respectively) and DC (90, 534 and 1360 s for skilled, intermediates and novices) was significantly shorter for skilled participants (both p < .01). Nineteen out of the 22 items composing the realism survey obtained "very favorable" and "favorable" scores. Educational content was designated as "very favorable". Mental, physical, and technical demands were gradually higher the lower the initial level of experience.
Reperfused human cadaver model has the potential to be valid simulation tool for diagnostic colonoscopy training.
再灌注的人体尸体是一种经过验证的手术模拟器。我们旨在将其用作结肠镜检查模拟器。
纳入了胃肠内窥镜检查的新手、中级和熟练参与者。他们在再灌注的人体尸体上进行了一次结肠镜检查,并报告了到达率、到达解剖学标志所需的时间和长度,以进行构建有效性分析。我们还评估了我们的模型真实性(SRS 调查)、教育内容(CVS 调查)和任务负荷(NASA-TLX 指数)。如果项目评分≥5/7 且四分位距(IQR)重叠四个,则定义为“有利”,如果评分≥5/7 且 IQR 排除四个,则定义为“非常有利”(中立)。主要终点是直肠乙状结肠交界处(RSJ)到达率和降结肠(DC)到达时间。次要目标是 SRS、CVS 和 NASA-TLX 问卷结果。
共纳入 11 名熟练参与者、5 名中级参与者和 8 名新手。熟练参与者到达 RSJ 的频率高于新手和中级组,分别为 100%、80%和 75%,但差异无统计学意义。他们更频繁地到达 DC(熟练组为 100%,中级组为 80%,新手组为 50%,p=0.018)。到达 RSJ 的中位数时间(熟练组、中级组和新手组分别为 59、272 和 686s)和 DC(熟练组、中级组和新手组分别为 90、534 和 1360s)均显著缩短,(均 p<0.01)。组成现实感调查的 22 个项目中的 19 个获得了“非常有利”和“有利”的分数。教育内容被指定为“非常有利”。心理、生理和技术需求随着初始经验水平的降低而逐渐升高。
再灌注人体尸体模型具有成为诊断结肠镜检查培训有效模拟工具的潜力。