Clinical Department 5, University of Medicine and Pharmacy Carol Davila, Bucharest, Romania.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Medicine and Pharmacy Carol Davila, Bucharest, Romania.
Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 2022 Dec;159 Suppl 1(Suppl 1):126-136. doi: 10.1002/ijgo.14482.
To assess women's perceptions of the quality of maternal and newborn care (QMNC) received in hospitals in Romania during the COVID-19 pandemic by mode of birth.
A validated anonymous online questionnaire based on WHO quality measures. Subgroup analysis of spontaneous vaginal birth (SVB), emergency cesarean, and elective cesarean and multivariate analyses were performed, and QMNC indexes were calculated. Maternal age, educational level, year of birth, mother born in Romania, parity, type of hospital, and type of professionals assisting the birth were used for multivariate analysis.
A total of 620 women completed the survey. Overall, several quality measures suggested gaps in QMNC in Romania, with the lowest QMNC indexes reported for provision of care and availability of resources. Women who had either elective or emergency cesarean compared with those who had SVB more frequently lacked early breastfeeding (OR 2.04 and 2.13, respectively), skin-to-skin contact (OR 1.73 and 1.75, respectively), rooming-in (OR 2.07 and 1.96, respectively), and exclusive breastfeeding at discharge (OR 2.27 and 1.64, respectively). Compared with elective cesarean, emergency cesarean had higher odds of ineffective communication by healthcare providers (OR 1.65), lack of involvement in choices (OR 1.58), insufficient emotional support (OR 2.07), and no privacy (OR 2.06). Compared with other modes of birth, a trend for lower QMNC indexes for emergency cesarean was observed for all domains, while for elective cesarean the QMNC index for provision of care was significantly lower.
Quality indicators of perinatal care remain behind targets in Romania, with births by cesarean the most affected.
NCT04847336.
通过分娩方式评估罗马尼亚 COVID-19 大流行期间妇女对医院母婴保健质量(QMNC)的认知。
基于世卫组织质量指标的经过验证的匿名在线问卷。对自然阴道分娩(SVB)、紧急剖宫产和选择性剖宫产进行了亚组分析,并进行了多变量分析,计算了 QMNC 指数。母亲年龄、教育水平、出生年份、罗马尼亚出生的母亲、产次、医院类型和协助分娩的专业人员类型用于多变量分析。
共有 620 名妇女完成了调查。总体而言,罗马尼亚的一些 QMNC 质量措施存在差距,提供的护理和资源的可用性方面报告的 QMNC 指数最低。与 SVB 相比,行选择性或紧急剖宫产的女性更频繁地缺乏早期母乳喂养(OR 2.04 和 2.13)、皮肤接触(OR 1.73 和 1.75)、母婴同室(OR 2.07 和 1.96)以及出院时纯母乳喂养(OR 2.27 和 1.64)。与选择性剖宫产相比,紧急剖宫产时医护人员的沟通效果更差(OR 1.65)、参与决策的机会更少(OR 1.58)、情感支持不足(OR 2.07)和缺乏隐私(OR 2.06)的可能性更高。与其他分娩方式相比,紧急剖宫产的所有领域的 QMNC 指数都呈下降趋势,而选择性剖宫产的护理提供 QMNC 指数显著降低。
罗马尼亚的围产期护理质量指标仍落后于目标,剖宫产分娩受影响最大。