Gelgie Aga E, Cavalerie Lisa, Kaba Mirgissa, Asrat Daniel, Mor Siobhan M
College of Veterinary Medicine and Agriculture, Addis Ababa University, P.O. Box 34, Bishoftu, Ethiopia.
Department of Animal Science, Institute of Agriculture, The University of Tennessee, 2506 River Drive Brehm Animal Science Bldg, TN, USA.
One Health. 2022 Oct 18;15:100450. doi: 10.1016/j.onehlt.2022.100450. eCollection 2022 Dec.
Rabies is an important zoonosis in Ethiopia, where lack of research is cited as a constraint to implementation of the national rabies control strategy. We conducted a systematic review of publications and theses on rabies in Ethiopia, to document research gaps and areas of knowledge saturation in relation to geographic and species focus, methods and findings. We also examined funding sources and extent of local researcher participation. After screening titles and abstracts, the full text of 119 publications was included in data extraction. More than 40% of publications involved data collection in one region (Oromia); no publications reported findings from Benishangul-Gumuz, Dire Dawa or Gambella. Dogs and wildlife (especially ) were the focus of research in 45% and 24% publications, respectively. Descriptive epidemiology ( = 39 publications), ethno-medicine/-pharmacology ( = 17) and knowledge, attitude, and practice surveys (KAP, = 15) were amongst the most common study designs, while studies involving economic methods ( = 3) and experimental epidemiology to test interventions ( = 3) were under-represented. Incidence surveys ( = 9) commonly used post-exposure prophylaxis administration in humans as a proxy for exposure without laboratory confirmation of the rabies status of the animal. KAP surveys tended to highlight reasonable levels of knowledge of rabies and poor practices, including overreliance on medicinal plants. International researchers were the first or last (senior) author on 42% and 58% of publications, respectively, most of which were funded by international organizations (45/72 publications reporting funding source). Based on this systematic review, we suggest more applied research is needed to address gaps in laboratory surveillance (including in humans, domestic and wild animals); identify effective ways to overcome socio-cultural and other barriers to accessing effective rabies treatments; inform best approaches to incentivizing mass dog vaccination programs; and generate local estimates of the cost-benefit and cost-effectiveness of different control strategies to improve financing and political buy-in for rabies control in Ethiopia.
狂犬病是埃塞俄比亚一种重要的人畜共患病,该国缺乏相关研究被认为是实施国家狂犬病防控战略的一个制约因素。我们对埃塞俄比亚有关狂犬病的出版物和论文进行了系统综述,以记录在地理和物种重点、方法及研究结果方面的研究空白和知识饱和领域。我们还研究了资金来源以及当地研究人员的参与程度。在筛选标题和摘要后,119篇出版物的全文被纳入数据提取。超过40%的出版物涉及在一个地区(奥罗米亚)的数据收集;没有出版物报道来自本尚古勒-古穆兹、德雷达瓦或甘贝拉的研究结果。狗和野生动物(尤其是 )分别是45%和24%出版物的研究重点。描述性流行病学( = 39篇出版物)、民族医学/药理学( = 17篇)以及知识、态度和实践调查(KAP, = 15篇)是最常见的研究设计类型,而涉及经济方法( = 3篇)和用于测试干预措施的实验流行病学( = 3篇)的研究较少。发病率调查( = 9篇)通常将人类的暴露后预防接种作为动物狂犬病暴露状态未经实验室确认时的替代指标。KAP调查往往突出了对狂犬病的合理认知水平以及不良做法,包括过度依赖药用植物。国际研究人员分别是42%和58%出版物的第一作者或最后(资深)作者,其中大多数由国际组织资助(72篇报告资金来源的出版物中有45篇)。基于这项系统综述,我们建议需要开展更多应用研究,以填补实验室监测方面的空白(包括在人类、家养动物和野生动物方面);确定有效方法来克服获取有效狂犬病治疗的社会文化和其他障碍;为激励大规模犬类疫苗接种计划提供最佳方法;并对不同控制策略的成本效益和成本效果进行本地估算,以改善埃塞俄比亚狂犬病防控的资金投入和政治支持。