Kim Doo-Young, Choi Kang-Ho, Kim Ja-Hae, Hong Jina, Choi Seong-Min, Park Man-Seok, Cho Ki-Hyun
Department of Artificial Intelligence Convergence, Chonnam National University, Gwangju, Korea (the Republic of).
Department of Neurology, Chonnam National University Medical School and Hospital, Gwangju, Korea (the Republic of)
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2023 May;94(5):369-378. doi: 10.1136/jnnp-2022-330230. Epub 2023 Jan 17.
Whether deep learning models using clinical data and brain imaging can predict the long-term risk of major adverse cerebro/cardiovascular events (MACE) after acute ischaemic stroke (AIS) at the individual level has not yet been studied.
A total of 8590 patients with AIS admitted within 5 days of symptom onset were enrolled. The primary outcome was the occurrence of MACEs (a composite of stroke, acute myocardial infarction or death) over 12 months. The performance of deep learning models (DeepSurv and Deep-Survival-Machines (DeepSM)) and traditional survival models (Cox proportional hazards (CoxPH) and random survival forest (RSF)) were compared using the time-dependent concordance index ([Formula: see text] index).
Given the top 1 to all 60 clinical factors according to feature importance, CoxPH and RSF yielded [Formula: see text] index of 0.7236-0.8222 and 0.7279-0.8335, respectively. Adding image features improved the performance of deep learning models and traditional models assisted by deep learning models. DeepSurv and DeepSM yielded the best [Formula: see text] index of 0.8496 and 0.8531 when images were added to all 39 relevant clinical factors, respectively. In feature importance, brain image was consistently ranked highly. Deep learning models automatically extracted the image features directly from personalised brain images and predicted the risk and date of future MACEs at the individual level.
Deep learning models using clinical data and brain images could improve the prediction of MACEs and provide personalised outcome prediction for patients with AIS. Deep learning models will allow us to develop more accurate and tailored prognostic prediction systems that outperform traditional models.
利用临床数据和脑成像的深度学习模型能否在个体水平上预测急性缺血性卒中(AIS)后发生重大不良脑血管/心血管事件(MACE)的长期风险,目前尚未得到研究。
共纳入8590例症状发作后5天内入院的AIS患者。主要结局是12个月内发生的MACE(卒中、急性心肌梗死或死亡的复合事件)。使用时间依赖性一致性指数([公式:见正文]指数)比较深度学习模型(DeepSurv和深度生存机器(DeepSM))和传统生存模型(Cox比例风险模型(CoxPH)和随机生存森林(RSF))的性能。
根据特征重要性给出前1至全部60个临床因素,CoxPH和RSF的[公式:见正文]指数分别为0.7236 - 0.8222和0.7279 - 0.8335。添加图像特征可提高深度学习模型以及由深度学习模型辅助的传统模型的性能。当将图像添加到所有39个相关临床因素时,DeepSurv和DeepSM分别产生了最佳的[公式:见正文]指数0.8496和0.8531。在特征重要性方面,脑图像一直排名靠前。深度学习模型直接从个性化脑图像中自动提取图像特征,并在个体水平上预测未来MACE的风险和发生日期。
利用临床数据和脑图像的深度学习模型可以改善对MACE的预测,并为AIS患者提供个性化的结局预测。深度学习模型将使我们能够开发出比传统模型更准确、更具针对性的预后预测系统。